More from tonsky.me
A while ago I was reading about Wayland and this quote stuck with me: A stated goal of Wayland is “every frame is perfect”. And I think this is a goal we should all aspire to. Wayland is talking about the technical side of things (modern GPU stacks are very complex and Wayland is trying to take control back) but it could be applied to UI too. The rule of thumb is: If I take a screenshot of your app at any moment, it must make sense Why care about every frame? It builds trust. Users can’t see the code, so UI is the only way for them to judge the quality of the app. If UI looks good, that means developers had time to polish it, which means that they probably spent a comparable amount of time to iron out the code. It’s a heuristic, but a reasonable one. Now, what does it mean in practice? I can think of a few things: No white flashes between screens. No partially loaded content. No relayout while content loads. Internally consistent. If one part of the UI says “1 update available”, another part should not say “Checking for updates...” Precise animations. Animations often end up being forgotten. A UI might look great in both start and end states but very janky in between. Like this: If you feel like there are weird things going on there, there are! Look at slowed down version: Now let’s apply our rule and take screenshots in the middle of the animation. This doesn’t look right: Neither does this: Both of these frames are not perfect. Let’s look at another example. Safari: Placeholder text here moves from the center but cursor animates from the left position: Not the end of the world by any means, but it does create a feeling that these two components are not in sync with each other. Next thought: maybe they weren’t designed together? If so, then they might not work well together. That’s how trust is lost. This desynchronization can lead to a lot of confusion. For example, in Photos, when switching between Crop and Adjust mode, picture snaps into place immediately but the crop border is animated: This creates a false feeling that something subtly changes when you switch between modes. And you know what? I don’t want my UI to give me false feelings. I want it to be a precise instrument, not an animated toy. Sometimes animations are supposed to help you understand a transition, so it’s doubly sad when they make it harder. Follow the magnifying glass: Same with Youtube. They had the simplest task in the world: move a rectangle from one position to another! Yet they decided to do something very strange: Can you explain this? Does it make sense? Probably a technical limitation of the DOM architecture they decided earlier on. I call these situations “The technology has outsmarted the programmer”. But no matter the reason, the result is an imperfect frame. Sometimes animations are left out as an afterthought. Whatever happens, happens. Then we get this: The details are fascinating to watch: So yeah. Please pay attention not only to the start and end states, but also to everything in between. Every frame matters. I’ll leave you with this unprovoked zoom animation from Preview app. Take care!
In “Why is Claude an Electron App?” Drew Breunig wonders: Claude spent $20k on an agent swarm implementing (kinda) a C-compiler in Rust, but desktop Claude is an Electron app. If code is free, why aren’t all apps native? And then argues that the answer is that LLMs are not good enough yet. They can do 90% of the work, so there’s still a substantial amount of manual polish, and thus, increased costs. But I think that’s not the real reason. The real reason is: native has nothing to offer. API-wise, native apps lost to web apps a long time ago. Native APIs are terrible to use, and OS vendors use everything in their power to make you not want to develop native apps for their platform. That explains the rise of Electron before LLM times, but it’s also a problem that LLMs solve now: if that was a real barrier to developing native apps, it doesn’t exist anymore. Then there’re looks and consistency. Some time ago, maybe in the late 90s and 2000s, native was ahead. It used to look good, it was consistent, and it all actually worked: the more apps used native look and feel, the better user experience was across apps (which we used to call programs). These days, though, native is as bad as the web, if not worse. Consistency is basically out the window. Anything can look like anything, buttons have no borders, contrast doesn’t exist, and neither do conventions. Apple, for example, seems to place traffic lights and corner radius by vibes rather than by any measurable guidelines. Maybe the server should round the corners? Looks could be good, but they also can be bad, and then you are stuck with platform-consistent, but generally bad UI (Liquid Glass ahem). It changes too often, too: the app you made today will look out of place next year, when Apple decides to change look and feel yet again. There’s no native look anymore. Computer UIs also degrade over time Theoretically, native apps can integrate with OS on a deeper level. This sounds nice, but what does that mean in practice? There are almost no good interoperable file formats; everything is locked inside individual apps, most services moved to the web, and OSes dropped the ball for making a good shared baseline. You can integrate with OS-provided calendar, but you can’t do it with web calendar. Well, you can, of course, but it’s easier on the web; native doesn’t help with it at all. Web pages only lead to more web pages Finally, the last hope of people longing for native is performance. They feel that native apps will be faster. Well, they can, but it doesn’t mean they will. Web apps can be faster, too, but in practice, nobody cares. There’s no technical reason why Slack needs to load 80 MiB just to show 10 channel names and 3 messages on a screen. The web is not the problem here! It’s a choice to be bad. What makes you think it’ll be different once the company decides to move to native? Don’t get me wrong: writing this brings me no joy. I don’t think web is a solution either. I just remember good times when native did a better-than-average job, and we were all better for using it, and it saddens me that these times have passed. I just don’t think that kidding ourselves that the only problem with software is Electron and it all will be butterflies and unicorns once we rewrite Slack in SwiftUI is not productive. The real problem is a lack of care. And the slop; you can build it with any stack.
I have a weird relationship with statistics: on one hand, I try not to look at it too often. Maybe once or twice a year. It’s because analytics is not actionable: what difference does it make if a thousand people saw my article or ten thousand? I mean, sure, you might try to guess people’s tastes and only write about what’s popular, but that will destroy your soul pretty quickly. On the other hand, I feel nervous when something is not accounted for, recorded, or saved for future reference. I might not need it now, but what if ten years later I change my mind? Seeing your readers also helps to know you are not writing into the void. So I really don’t need much, something very basic: the number of readers per day/per article, maybe, would be enough. Final piece of the puzzle: I self-host my web projects, and I use an old-fashioned web server instead of delegating that task to Nginx. Static sites are popular and for a good reason: they are fast, lightweight, and fulfil their function. I, on the other hand, might have an unfinished gestalt or two: I want to feel the full power of the computer when serving my web pages, to be able to do fun stuff that is beyond static pages. I need that freedom that comes with a full programming language at your disposal. I want to program my own web server (in Clojure, sorry everybody else). Existing options All this led me on a quest for a statistics solution that would uniquely fit my needs. Google Analytics was out: bloated, not privacy-friendly, terrible UX, Google is evil, etc. What is going on? Some other JS solution might’ve been possible, but still questionable: SaaS? Paid? Will they be around in 10 years? Self-host? Are their cookies GDPR-compliant? How to count RSS feeds? Nginx has access logs, so I tried server-side statistics that feed off those (namely, Goatcounter). Easy to set up, but then I needed to create domains for them, manage accounts, monitor the process, and it wasn’t even performant enough on my server/request volume! My solution So I ended up building my own. You are welcome to join, if your constraints are similar to mine. This is how it looks: It’s pretty basic, but does a few things that were important to me. Setup Extremely easy to set up. And I mean it as a feature. Just add our middleware to your Ring stack and get everything automatically: collecting and reporting. (def app (-> routes ... (ring.middleware.params/wrap-params) (ring.middleware.cookies/wrap-cookies) ... (clj-simple-stats.core/wrap-stats))) ;; <-- just add this It’s zero setup in the best sense: nothing to configure, nothing to monitor, minimal dependency. It starts to work immediately and doesn’t ask anything from you, ever. See, you already have your web server, why not reuse all the setup you did for it anyway? Request types We distinguish between request types. In my case, I am only interested in live people, so I count them separately from RSS feed requests, favicon requests, redirects, wrong URLs, and bots. Bots are particularly active these days. Gotta get that AI training data from somewhere. RSS feeds are live people in a sense, so extra work was done to count them properly. Same reader requesting feed.xml 100 times in a day will only count as one request. Hosted RSS readers often report user count in User-Agent, like this: Feedly/1.0 (+http://www.feedly.com/fetcher.html; 457 subscribers; like FeedFetcher-Google) Mozilla/5.0 (compatible; BazQux/2.4; +https://bazqux.com/fetcher; 6 subscribers) Feedbin feed-id:1373711 - 142 subscribers My personal respect and thank you to everybody on this list. I see you. Graphs Visualization is important, and so is choosing the correct graph type. This is wrong: Continuous line suggests interpolation. It reads like between 1 visit at 5am and 11 visits at 6am there were points with 2, 3, 5, 9 visits in between. Maybe 5.5 visits even! That is not the case. This is how a semantically correct version of that graph should look: Some attention was also paid to having reasonable labels on axes. You won’t see something like 117, 234, 10875. We always choose round numbers appropriate to the scale: 100, 200, 500, 1K etc. Goes without saying that all graphs have the same vertical scale and syncrhonized horizontal scroll. Insights We don’t offer much (as I don’t need much), but you can narrow reports down by page, query, referrer, user agent, and any date slice. Not implemented (yet) It would be nice to have some insights into “What was this spike caused by?” Some basic breakdown by country would be nice. I do have IP addresses (for what they are worth), but I need a way to package GeoIP into some reasonable size (under 1 Mb, preferably; some loss of resolution is okay). Finally, one thing I am really interested in is “Who wrote about me?” I do have referrers, only question is how to separate signal from noise. Performance. DuckDB is a sport: it compresses data and runs column queries, so storing extra columns per row doesn’t affect query performance. Still, each dashboard hit is a query across the entire database, which at this moment (~3 years of data) sits around 600 MiB. I definitely need to look into building some pre-calculated aggregates. One day. How to get Head to github.com/tonsky/clj-simple-stats and follow the instructions: Let me know what you think! Is it usable to you? What could be improved? P.S. You can try the live example at tonsky.me/stats. The data was imported from Nginx access logs, which I turned on and off on a few occasions, so it’s a bit spotty. Still, it should give you a general idea.
More in programming
Five days and 540km on a bike across Kyushu, without a laptop. Notes on the peace of riding all day, convenience store dinners, and Japan's emptying countryside.
I found a wonderful free crochet pattern for the Pokémon Ditto from Loops by Kat, but I decided I wanted to make a version with more than 3 "leg" blobs like the original pattern had. Specifically, I wanted to add two more smaller blobs in the back to help stabilize Ditto when they're sitting and also add a butt to our favorite transforming blob. Hazel Knits Cadence, a worsted weight superwash merino, in Terrywinkle that I had in my stash (I used about a third of the skein/36 grams/66 yards/60 meters), and I crocheted with a 2.5 mm hook. I make very tightly stitched amigurumi - do whatever is a good fit for you and your yarn! I used two 6 mm round safety eyes, and I embroidered the mouth with scraps of Hazelknits Cadence in Coral, Bloom, and Signature Black. The above photo is more true to color than some of the ones I took where Ditto looks more pink. I made Ditto's 2 additional booty blobs intentionally off-center by embracing the natural lean of crochet stitches - this gives a more animated or "in motion" feel to Ditto. As an added bonus, this simplifies the pattern as everyone's tension will be a little different, and thus everyone's off-centering a little delightfully different, too, but centering it instead wouldn't be the same for everyone! Here's all the information to modify Kat's crochet pattern to create a 5-blobbed Ditto. I use US crochet terminology. This pattern modification is also available as a pdf. Follow Kat's pattern through round 13. At round 14, it's time to start modifying to add the space and shaping for the additional blobs. There are also 3 more rows in this section to better fit the new 5-blob proportions. Modified increases in body, beginning at round 14 (with additional rounds, too): Round 14: 3 sc, 1 inc, 46 sc, 1 inc, 3 sc (56) Round 15: 56 sc (56) Round 16: 2 sc, 1 inc, 2 sc, 1 inc, 44 sc, 1 inc, 2 sc, 1 inc, 2 sc (60) Round 17: 60 sc (60) Round 18: inc, 4 sc, inc, 48 sc, inc, 5 sc (63) Round 19: 63 sc (63) Round 20: dec (through front loop of first stitch and both loops of second stitch), inc, 9 sc, inc, 38 sc, inc, 11 sc (65) At this point, the original pattern suggests placing the safety eyes, but I think it makes more sense to do this after you've made the "butt" and divided the stitches the 3 main "front" "leg" blobs from the original pattern. You'll still have plenty of access to place them then. Roadmap for doing 5 "leg" blobs instead of 3 To make 5 blobs, you use some of the main body's stitches and some created stitches for each. Created stitches are a combination of chains, pickups on the back of chains, pickups in the connections between the chains and the main body, and pickups in the connections between the chains. The "butt" "leg"/mounds are created before the 3 original "legs," and the left "butt" "leg"/mound is made before the right one. 1. Left "butt" "leg"/mound: This is the left "butt" cheek when viewed from the bottom. (While this is really the right butt cheek from Ditto's perspective, I'm calling it left because we're crocheting while viewing from below so it's backwards.) The start of round is the same as the start of round from making the body of the blob, so you can continue as usual. Round 1: 13 sc, chain 11 (24) Round 2: connect chain at previous start of round (skipping 52 stitches) then 24 sc (24) Round 3: (6 sc, dec) x 3 (21) Round 4: (2 sc, dec, 3 sc) x 3 (18) Round 5: (sc, dec) x 6 (12) Round 6: 6 dec (6) Finish off by looping through front loops of all 6 stitches and pull tight, etc. 2. Right "butt" "leg"/mound: This is the right "butt" cheek when viewed from the bottom. The start of round for this "butt" "leg" is 12 stitches before the body/left "butt" leg start of round. This is the second stitch in an increase from the last round of the body. Round 1: 12 sc, 1 dec in the corner of body connected to first "butt" "leg" (pictured below), 4 sc in the bottom loops in the existing chain, chain 7 (24) Round 2: connect chain at start of round for this "butt" "leg" (skipping other blob's additional 7 chains and 40 stitches in the main body) then 24 sc (24) Round 3: (6 sc, dec) x 3 (21) Round 4: (2 sc, dec, 3 sc) x 3 (18) Round 5: (sc, dec) x 6 (12) Round 6: 6 dec (6) Finish off by looping through front loops of all 6 stitches and pull tight, etc. Getting back to the original pattern for the 3 main "legs": After both "butt" "legs"/mounds are done, there are 40 stitches on the original body, 7 chain stitches that can be picked up from each "butt" leg" that haven't been picked up in a second location, which totals the original 54 stitches - this sets you up for the 3 blobs as described in the original pattern. Between each "butt" "leg" and the main body and between the two "butt" "legs" themselves are an additional 3 connections that are also picked up and decreased appropriately to keep the seams between "legs" tight. As a reminder, here's the road map, which shows how to divide up these stitches for the Ditto's main three "legs:" You might find it helpful to visualize this division by temporarily stringing up some scrap yarn to preview the divisions: If you'd like, place stitch markers like I did to delineate the division: Now that you've visualized how you're dividing the main "leg" blobs, it's a good time to place safety eyes if you're using safety eyes for eyes. I placed mine between rows 7 and 8 counted down from the small head blob and left 8 stitches between the eyes. Now you can proceed to make the main legs in the same order as the original pattern. 3. Main "leg" blob 1: This is the left "leg" blob labeled 1 in the original pattern. To start, connect your yarn into the first stitch in the main body after where the main body meets the left "butt" mound. Round 1: 18 sc, chain 9, 1 sc in the 2nd bottom loop in the chain right of the body/left "butt" mound connection, dec through the leftmost bottom loop in the chain on the left "butt" mound and the loop on top of the meeting of the main body/left "butt" mound (pictured below). (29) In the start of the original pattern "leg" 1, here are the two loops in the decrease through the left most chain loop on the left "butt" mound and the loop on top of the meeting of the main body/left "butt" mound. Follow the original pattern's Rounds 19 to 23 and finish off blob "leg" 1 as written. 4. Main "leg" blob 2: This is the right "leg" blob labeled 2 in the original pattern. To start, connect your yarn into 15th stitch from where the main body meets the right "butt" mound - there should be 7 skipped stitches along the front of the Ditto between this start of round and the left "leg" blob's last stitch on the front side of Ditto before the chaining. Round 1: 15 sc, dec through the loop on top of the meeting of the main body/right "butt" mound and the rightmost bottom loop in the chain on the right "butt" mound (pictured below), 4 sc in the bottom loops in the chain on the right "butt" mound, chain 9 (29) In the start of the original pattern "leg" 2, here are the two loops in the decrease through the loop on top of the meeting of the main body/right "butt" mound and the rightmost chain loop on the right "butt" mound. Connect chain at start of round for this blob "leg" at the beginning of round 2's first sc and continue the original pattern's Rounds 2 to 6 for blob "leg" 2 as written. As in the original pattern, now is a good time to stuff your Ditto most of the way! 5. Main "leg" blob 3: This is the center "leg" blob labeled 3 in the original pattern. Round 1: Start in the corner next to left "leg" 1 on the front side (pictured below). 37 sc into the following stitches you pick up: 7 stitches along the main body 1 stitch in the corner of the main body and right "leg" 2 9 stitches in the bottom loops of the chain along right "leg" 2 1 stitch in the corner of right "leg" 2 and the right "butt" mound 2 stitches in the bottom loops of the chain along the right "butt" mound 1 stitch in the corner between the two "butt" mounds 5 stitches in the bottom loops of the chain along the left "butt" mound 1 stitch in the corner of the left "butt" mound and left "leg" 1 9 stitches in the bottom loops of the chain along left "leg" 1 1 stitch in the corner of left "leg" 1 and the main body (37) My lime green running stitch marker indicates the start of round pickup location for making the main blob "leg" 3. To compensate for the extra 5 stitches from those corners, I decreased in the second round at the corresponding locations instead of just single crocheting the whole way around to ensure the end of my round 2 of this section had the specified 32 stitches: Round 2: 6 sc, dec, 8 sc, dec, sc, dec, 4 sc, dec, 8 sc, dec (32) After round 2, I continued with the rest of the original pattern to finish the middle blob "leg" 3. Make the two arms according to the original pattern. I attached them less symmetrically than the original suggested. Finally, embroider a mouth for Ditto. You can either do this in black to match the safety eyes or create a two-toned mouth in red and pink to make a very happy looking Ditto like I did. FYI, this is also documented as a project on Ravelry (though it's a lot harder to follow since photos couldn't be inline).
Being focused is about doing less things, and giving more space to the stuff that matters. I am spread out on too many projects and I can’t give enough attention to all of them. It’s time to clearly sort out which one I will keep maintaining and which I should drop entirely. Chuttersnap Mikochi Mikochi is a self-hostable remote file manager I’ve started in 2023. It’s my most successful open source project. I personally use it every day, and thousands of people have adopted it and started using it on their own servers. This year the project has been receiving more and more attention. Maybe it just reached a critical mass of users. In practice, that means a bit more maintenance work, since people have been pointing out bugs and suggesting new features. At the same time, working on Mikochi is fairly enjoyable. It’s a small, self-contained project made with technologies I enjoy working with. I’ve got no complaints about spending some time working on it. Verdict: Keep maintaining Mikochi and actively continue improving it. Itako Itako is an investment portfolio tracking SaaS. I built it for the most part between 2023 and 2025. In terms of scope, it’s the largest project I’ve done entirely by myself. Is it a success? Not really. There are definitely a lot of people who tried Itako, and some who’ve kept using it a bit. But it’s not engaging enough for anyone to consider getting the premium plan. And honestly I don’t find myself using it that much. My view of investing and portfolio management has significantly shifted since I started this project. While I used to think that more sophisticated analysis would lead to better returns, I now realize that the only strategies that consistently make money are honestly stupidly simple. Or maybe it’s a U curve: on one end you’ve got a monkey throwing darts, on the other end you’ve got Jane Street, and everyone in-between fails to beat the market. Anyway, the biggest issue with Itako is how dull working on it is. The interesting parts of the projects are working on statistics and data visualization. But in practice, 90% of the time is spent tediously fixing data, understanding why some German stocks have an exchange labelled XETRA instead of XETR, why some Belgian stocks still have quotes while Euronext shows them as delisted… Verdict: Shut down Itako today. Milou Milou is static site generator for press kits. It started as a fork of presskit.html which was completely abandoned at the time. It’s a very useful tool. At Tsukumogami, it’s part of our Cloudflare pipeline which builds our website in a few minutes whenever we need to change something. It seems like a few other game studios have picked it up, although I rarely get any feedback about it. I’ve not spent too much time working on it in 2026. I think it could be interesting to come back to it and add a feature or two. Better support for multiple languages could be an idea. At least, I need to make sure we don’t fall into the good old Node.js dependency rot. Verdict: Spend some time on Milou. Luluka Earlier this year, I created Luluka. It’s a CLI that allows previewing the output of Ebitengine shaders. I do still think Ebitengine is a great engine and Go is better suited for game development than most people realize. However, after quite a long period of experimentation around it, we’ve decided to remain a Godot studio. On top of having quite a large sunk cost in infrastructure surrounding Godot, the tooling and possibility of doing 3D games still makes it a more attractive engine for our use cases. And I’ve been doing a lot of 3D work lately, so better put those hours to use. Verdict: Archive the project. The rest I’ve had a lot of good ideas that stayed as almost empty repositories in my GitHub. For example, Hakumei was a terminal companion to Mikochi. I made a few commits on this project and never found the time to work on it again. I have to admit I’m probably never going to have the time to work on all those repositories. Time to archive them all!
This post was previously published through my newsletter on November 9, 2026. From time to time, I will republish newsletter issues on my blog here if I think people (and search engines) might benefit from it. If you want to read everything I’ve written once it is posted, I recommend signing up for the newsletter. If you’re doing anything to stay on top of what is happening in the world of software testing and test automation, like browsing or even posting on LinkedIn, which I stopped doing for the foreseeable future, or reading blog posts - my preferred way of keeping up these days, and I highly recommend Dawid Dylowicz’s excellent Software Testing Weekly aggregator mailing list if you prefer longer-form reading, too you’d be thinking that AI has consumed our entire field, and that everybody (or at least those who post or write in public) is an AI expert these days. The reality, though, is far from that. Yes, some people use a lot of AI, even when I would only call a small fraction of them ‘experts’. I definitely do not classify myself as an ‘AI expert’, by the way. A much larger group uses AI on a less frequent basis, and they’re getting some value out of it. Sometimes more, sometimes less. That’s the group I’m probably in. And then there’s a group of people who haven’t really been using a lot of AI at all so far, beyond maybe the odd prompt to ChatGPT or Claude. I don’t have the actual numbers, but I suspect that this group is a lot larger than you would think from browsing your feed or surfing the blogosphere. You just don’t see them, because they’re typically not the people who do a lot of work in public. A few weeks ago, I started working with a small group of testers to teach them how to use AI in their daily work. This work covers both test automation as well as broader software testing tasks, as some of them contribute to automation on a daily basis, but not all of them do. I’m working with them one day per week, on average, for three months, and we’re making small steps towards making AI a more prominent tool in their tool belt. So, what are we working on right now? I’m pulling ideas from my ‘Valuable Feedback, Fast with AI’ course, and so far, we’ve spent some time setting up Claude, going over some important concepts such as context windows, models, tokens, and (of course!) the probabilistic nature of LLMs, and what that means for the results they provide. We have gone through several initial conversations, using Claude to learn more about and review specific user stories, which was an excellent segue into using talking about MCPs and setting up a connection to both Jira and Confluence using the Atlassian MCP. Last week, we also started experimenting with writing straightforward skills to make it easier for Claude to repeat certain actions in a structured way. These actions ranged from reviewing stories and acceptance criteria to refactoring small chunks of code in their (Robot Framework-based) test automation suite. What I loved about this is the avalanche of ideas that popped up in their heads when they saw how easy it was to use Claude. We made a short to-do list of ideas to try out for the next couple of weeks, and I’m looking forward to seeing them getting more confident around using Claude. One thing I have noticed is that their level of comfort around using AI varies quite a bit. Some of them are naturally quite cautious, which means they’ll ask ‘can we really do this?’ and ‘should we really do this?’ frequently before even submitting a single prompt. This is a good habit, I think, but we’ll have to do some work to get them more comfortable with using LLMs, without losing too much of that caution. Others in the group are the opposite: I need to hold them back a little, because otherwise they’ll create a beautiful mess within days, simply because they see so many opportunities to use Claude in their work. That, too, isn’t inherently bad, but I do want to teach them not just how to get the most out of an LLM, but also (more so) how to use AI prudently. Over the next couple of months, we’ll dive deeper into writing better prompts, creating and structuring skills, better context management, and creating and using agents, and probably a few more things, too. I’m looking forward to seeing these people grow more comfortable around using AI in their daily work, and figuring out where AI genuinely adds value and where it doesn’t in their own context. Is there a deeper message in this newsletter? Maybe not, and I’m just happy to tell you about this project, and how it is a great example of a what I call ‘corporate mentoring’, a very efficient way of teaching a small group of engineers new skills, within their own context. But maybe it’s also to show you that, despite what you might see on the Internet, especially those places featuring a lot of self-congratulation (I’m looking at you, LinkedIn), not everybody out there is an AI expert. At least not yet. So, if you feel like you’re ‘behind’ simply because you’re not running at least 17 agents continuously, creating 5400 merge requests per day, know that you’re not alone. Quite far from it, I would say.