Full Width [alt+shift+f] Shortcuts [alt+shift+k]
Sign Up [alt+shift+s] Log In [alt+shift+l]
72

AI Is Like a Lossy JPEG

from Jim Nielsen’s Blog [alt+shift+b] in programming

That’s something I’ve heard before — ChatGPT Is a Blurry JPEG of the Web — and it kind of made sense when I read it. But Paul Ford, writing in the Aboard Newsletter, helped it make even more sense in my brain. [AI tools] compress lots and lots of information—text, image, more—in a very lossy way, like a super-squeezed JPEG. Except instead of a single image, it’s “The Web” or “five million images.” The nice thing about lossy compression in a JPEG is that it’s obvious. You can see the compression artifacts. But with AI? Not so much: because of the way AI works, constantly guessing and filling in blanks, you can’t see the artifacts. It just keeps going until people have twelve fingers, stereotypes get reaffirmed, utter nonsense gets spewed, and so forth. You can see the forest, but the trees are all weird. What you end up with is text that looks like knowledge, but like a lossy JPEG, upon closer inspection you will find a lack of clarity. As Paul notes, you end up seeing the forest but zoom in to the details of any tree and stuff doesn’t looks right. AI is that: lossy compression, but on the level of knowledge not pixels. It follows that, as Paul notes, you end up with not only a tool whose output is akin to the lossy, visual artifacts of a JPEG, but a tool whose output introduces into the world the cognitive and social equivalent of those big blocky compression artifacts of a JPEG. As more and more people create, consume, and communicate with AI, more and more people will begin to understand themselves through a lens of lossyness — a lack of clarity. As Marshall McLuhan said: we shape our tools and then our tools shape us. Paul raises one last parallel of AI, it’s like a “slightly high intern”: You can’t really trust their output, but they do help you move things along. They’re good at using the web to gather stuff. They’re bright [but their] teen brains can’t quite figure out why you want this stuff, just that they have to do it...So they do what you ask,...
4th Mar 2024

Stay updated

Get a weekly newsletter with the top 5 articles worth reading every week.

More from Jim Nielsen’s Blog

Browser APIs: The Web’s Free SaaS

Authentication on the web is a complicated problem. If you’re going to do it yourself, there’s a lot you have to take into consideration. But odds are, you’re building an app whose core offering has nothing to do with auth. You don’t care about auth. It’s an implementation detail. So rather than spend your precious time solving the problem of auth, you pay someone else to solve it. That’s the value of SaaS. What would be the point of paying for an authentication service, like workOS, then re-implementing auth on your own? They have dedicated teams working on that problem. It’s unlikely you’re going to do it better than them and still deliver on the product you’re building. There’s a parallel here, I think, to building stuff in the browser. Browsers provide lots of features to help you deliver good websites fast to an incredibly broad and diverse audience. Browser makers have teams of people who, day-in and day-out, are spending lots of time developing and optimizing new their offerings. So if you leverage what they offer you, that gives you an advantage because you don’t have to build it yourself. You could build it yourself. You could say “No thanks, I don’t want what you have. I’ll make my own.” But you don’t have to. And odds are, whatever you do build yourself, is not likely to be as fast as the highly-optimized subsystems you can tie together in the browser. And the best part? Unlike SasS, you don’t have to pay for what the browser offers you. And because you’re not paying, it can’t be turned off if you stop paying. @view-transition, for example, is a free API that’ll work forever. That’s a great deal. Are you taking advantage? Email · Mastodon · Bluesky

2nd Nov 2025 • 14 votes
Doing It Manually

I have a standing desk that goes up and down via a manual crank. I’ve had it for probably ten years. Every time I raise or lower that thing, it gets my blood pumping. I often think: “I should upgrade to one of those standing desks that goes up and down with the push of a button.” Then there’s the other voice in my head: “Really? Are you so lazy you can’t put your snacks down, get out of your comfy chair, in your air conditioned room, and raise or lower your desk using a little elbow grease? That desk is just fine.” While writing this, I get out of my chair, star the timer, and raise my desk to standing position. 35 seconds. That’s the cost: 35 seconds, and an elevated heart rate. As I have many times over the last ten years, I recommit to keeping it — mostly as a reminder that it’s ok to do some things manually. Not everything in my life needs to be available to me at the push of a button. Email · Mastodon · Bluesky

2nd Oct 2025 • 86 votes
Trying to Make Sense of Casing Conventions on the Web

(I present to you my stream of consciousness on the topic of casing as it applies to the web platform.) I’m reading about the new command and commandfor attributes — which I’m super excited about, declarative behavior invocation in HTML? YES PLEASE!! — and one thing that strikes me is the casing in these APIs. For example, the command attribute has a variety of values in HTML which correspond to APIs in JavaScript. The show-popover attribute value maps to .showPopover() in JavaScript. hide-popover maps to .hidePopover(), etc. So what we have is: lowercase in attribute names e.g. commandfor="..." kebab-case in attribute values e.g. show-popover camelCase for JS counterparts e.g. showPopover() After thinking about this a little more, I remember that HTML attributes names are case insensitive, so the browser will normalize them to lowercase during parsing. Given that, I suppose you could write commandFor="..." but it’s effectively the same. Ok, lowercase attribute names in HTML makes sense. The related popover attributes follow the same convention: popovertarget popovertargetaction And there are many other attribute names in HTML that are lowercase, e.g.: maxlength novalidate contenteditable autocomplete formenctype So that all makes sense. But wait, there are some attribute names with hyphens in them, like aria-label="..." and data-value="...". So why isn’t it command-for="..."? Well, upon further reflection, I suppose those attributes were named that way for extensibility’s sake: they are essentially wildcard attributes that represent a family of attributes that are all under the same namespace: aria-* and data-*. But wait, isn’t that an argument for doing popover-target and popover-target-action? Or command and command-for? But wait (I keep saying that) there are kebab-case attribute names in HTML — like http-equiv on the <meta> tag, or accept-charset on the form tag — but those seem more like legacy exceptions. It seems like the only answer here is: there is no rule. Naming is driven by convention and decisions are made on a case-by-case basis. But if I had to summarize, it would probably be that the default casing for new APIs tends to follow the rules I outlined at the start (and what’s reflected in the new command APIs): lowercase for HTML attributes names kebab-case for HTML attribute values camelCase for JS counterparts Let’s not even get into SVG attribute names We need one of those “bless this mess” signs that we can hang over the World Wide Web. Email · Mastodon · Bluesky

4th Sep 2025 • 42 votes
A Few Things About the Anchor Element’s href You Might Not Have Known

I’ve written previously about reloading a document using only HTML but that got me thinking: What are all the values you can put in an anchor tag’s href attribute? Well, I looked around. I found some things I already knew about, e.g. Link protocols like mailto:, tel:, sms: and javascript: which deal with specific ways of handling links. Protocol-relative links, e.g. href="//" Text fragments for linking to specific pieces of text on a page, e.g. href="#:~:text=foo" But I also found some things I didn’t know about (or only vaguely knew about) so I wrote them down in an attempt to remember them. href="#" Scrolls to the top of a document. I knew that. But I’m writing because #top will also scroll to the top if there isn’t another element with id="top" in the document. I didn’t know that. (Spec: “If decodedFragment is an ASCII case-insensitive match for the string top, then return the top of the document.”) href="" Reloads the current page, preserving the search string but removing the hash string (if present). URL href="" resolves to /path/ /path/ /path/#foo /path/ /path/?id=foo /path/?id=foo /path/?id=foo#bar /path/?id=foo href="." Reloads the current page, removing both the search and hash strings (if present). Note: If you’re using href="." as a link to the current page, ensure your URLs have a trailing slash or you may get surprising navigation behavior. The path is interpreted as a file, so "." resolves to the parent directory of the current location. URL href="." resolves to /path / /path#foo / /path?id=foo / /path/ /path/ /path/#foo /path/ /path/?id=foo /path/ /path/index.html /path/ href="?" Reloads the current page, removing both the search and hash strings (if present). However, it preserves the ? character. Note: Unlike href=".", trailing slashes don’t matter. The search parameters will be removed but the path will be preserved as-is. URL href="?" resolves to /path /path? /path#foo /path? /path?id=foo /path? /path?id=foo#bar /path? /index.html /index.html? href="data:" You can make links that navigate to data URLs. The super-readable version of this would be: <a href="data:text/plain,hello world"> View plain text data URL </a> But you probably want data: URLs to be encoded so you don’t get unexpected behavior, e.g. <a href="data:text/plain,hello%20world"> View plain text data URL </a> Go ahead and try it (FYI: may not work in your user agent). Here’s a plain-text file and an HTML file. href="video.mp4#t=10,20" Media fragments allow linking to specific parts of a media file, like audio or video. For example, video.mp4#t=10,20 links to a video. It starts play at 10 seconds, and stops it at 20 seconds. (Support is limited at the time of this writing.) See For Yourself I tested a lot of this stuff in the browser and via JS. I think I got all these right. Thanks to JavaScript’s URL constructor (and the ability to pass a base URL), I could programmatically explore how a lot of these href’s would resolve. Here’s a snippet of the test code I wrote. You can copy/paste this in your console and they should all pass 🤞 const assertions = [ // Preserves search string but strips hash // x -> { search: '?...', hash: '' } { href: '', location: '/path', resolves_to: '/path' }, { href: '', location: '/path/', resolves_to: '/path/' }, { href: '', location: '/path/#foo', resolves_to: '/path/' }, { href: '', location: '/path/?id=foo', resolves_to: '/path/?id=foo' }, { href: '', location: '/path/?id=foo#bar', resolves_to: '/path/?id=foo' }, // Strips search and hash strings // x -> { search: '', hash: '' } { href: '.', location: '/path', resolves_to: '/' }, { href: '.', location: `/path#foo`, resolves_to: `/` }, { href: '.', location: `/path?id=foo`, resolves_to: `/` }, { href: '.', location: `/path/`, resolves_to: `/path/` }, { href: '.', location: `/path/#foo`, resolves_to: `/path/` }, { href: '.', location: `/path/?id=foo`, resolves_to: `/path/` }, { href: '.', location: `/path/index.html`, resolves_to: `/path/` }, // Strips search parameters and hash string, // but preserves search delimeter (`?`) // x -> { search: '?', hash: '' } { href: '?', location: '/path', resolves_to: '/path?' }, { href: '?', location: '/path#foo', resolves_to: '/path?' }, { href: '?', location: '/path?id=foo', resolves_to: '/path?' }, { href: '?', location: '/path/', resolves_to: '/path/?' }, { href: '?', location: '/path/?id=foo#bar', resolves_to: '/path/?' }, { href: '?', location: '/index.html#foo', resolves_to: '/index.html?'} ]; const assertions_evaluated = assertions.map(({ href, location, resolves_to }) => { const domain = 'https://example.com'; const expected = new URL(href, domain + location).toString(); const received = new URL(domain + resolves_to).toString(); return { href, location, expected: expected.replace(domain, ''), received: received.replace(domain, ''), passed: expected === received }; }); console.table(assertions_evaluated); Email · Mastodon · Bluesky

3rd Aug 2025 • 41 votes
Setting Element Ordering With HTML Rewriter Using CSS

After shipping my work transforming HTML with Netlify’s edge functions I realized I have a little bug: the order of the icons specified in the URL doesn’t match the order in which they are displayed on screen. Why’s this happening? I have a bunch of links in my HTML document, like this: <icon-list> <a href="/1/">…</a> <a href="/2/">…</a> <a href="/3/">…</a> <!-- 2000+ more --> </icon-list> I use html-rewriter in my edge function to strip out the HTML for icons not specified in the URL. So for a request to: /lookup?id=1&id=2 My HTML will be transformed like so: <icon-list> <!-- Parser keeps these two --> <a href="/1/">…</a> <a href="/2/">…</a> <!-- But removes this one --> <a href="/3/">…</a> </icon-list> Resulting in less HTML over the wire to the client. But what about the order of the IDs in the URL? What if the request is to: /lookup?id=2&id=1 Instead of: /lookup?id=1&id=2 In the source HTML document containing all the icons, they’re marked up in reverse chronological order. But the request for this page may specify a different order for icons in the URL. So how do I rewrite the HTML to match the URL’s ordering? The problem is that html-rewriter doesn’t give me a fully-parsed DOM to work with. I can’t do things like “move this node to the top” or “move this node to position x”. With html-rewriter, you only “see” each element as it streams past. Once it passes by, your chance at modifying it is gone. (It seems that’s just the way these edge function tools are designed to work, keeps them lean and performant and I can’t shoot myself in the foot). So how do I change the icon’s display order to match what’s in the URL if I can’t modify the order of the elements in the HTML? CSS to the rescue! Because my markup is just a bunch of <a> tags inside a custom element and I’m using CSS grid for layout, I can use the order property in CSS! All the IDs are in the URL, and their position as parameters has meaning, so I assign their ordering to each element as it passes by html-rewriter. Here’s some pseudo code: // Get all the IDs in the URL const ids = url.searchParams.getAll("id"); // Select all the icons in the HTML rewriter.on("icon-list a", { element: (element) => { // Get the ID const id = element.getAttribute('id'); // If it's in our list, set it's order // position from the URL if (ids.includes(id)) { const order = ids.indexOf(id); element.setAttribute( "style", `order: ${order}` ); // Otherwise, remove it } else { element.remove(); } }, }); Boom! I didn’t have to change the order in the source HTML document, but I can still get the displaying ordering to match what’s in the URL. I love shifty little workarounds like this! Email · Mastodon · Bluesky

2nd Jul 2025 • 33 votes

More in programming

AI Homelab Part 4: Lowering the floor for Scout

Helping Scout focus and remember

11 hours ago • 2 votes
The Explorer Pattern for product invention and development.

tl;dr: the Explorer Pattern is one individual or team building a functional implementation that minimizes cross-team and cross-functional impacts as much as humanly possible, and then reconciling the details with other teams after that prototype is completed, accepting that this approach can require very substantial rework to that initial development. Why write this? Imprint previously called this the “Tech-led” or “Engineering-led” development model, but it’s pretty unclear to folks what that means. This writeup provides a more defined term, the “Explorer Pattern”, and explains in more detail how this works. Why do we need to adjust the way we work? Before 2026: Code is expensive, and we design process to minimize implementation and rework In and after 2026: Writing software is extremely cheap, but it’s a wider phenomenon: generating output is effectively-free across many dimensions. Code is nearly free — if we have appropriate constraints. Designs are nearly free — if they follow patterns. Analysis is nearly free — if we’ve instrumented things properly Reworking software is extremely cheap. Historically industry has optimized around avoiding engineering rework because engineering was the highest cost / narrowest constraint. In many companies this was interpreted as writing code being the constraint, which was never true, but many common practices were designed as if that were true (e.g. bringing engineering into problem-solving late “to protect their time”) Working on the system is much more effective than historically if we get automated integration and feedback loops right, e.g. not improving a one-off design but improving the design system. Any place where improving the higher-leverage process is slower than solving the one-off is a bug in our process Explorer Pattern: primary-and-replicas metaphor The easiest metaphor to think about the Explorer Pattern is database replication. Databases like MySQL and PostgreSQL have a primary database, where writes are performed. Every write is verified at that point, and once it’s verified, you know that the writes will flow downstream to various secondary replicas. Those downstream replicas can be delayed but they can’t be wrong because writes are verified upstream. (I’ve resisted the desire to talk about the CAP theorem.) A different model for database design is that used by Dynamo or Cassandra (or MongoDB to a certain extent), where you have a replica set, and have to get an acknowledgement from the majority of the replica set for a write to be strongly consistent. This is a very reliable setup, because it means you can tolerate losing a node, but it also introduces inconsistencies, and on a fixed amount of hardware they tend to be much, much slower than running a primary-secondary setup (or rely on bad performance metrics that don’t fsync to disk to create the illusion of throughput). The Explorer Pattern is the former primary-secondary model, where the vast majority of the work is done by the working individual or team. This makes all work internally consistent because it’s passed through the same small group. It doesn’t, however, mean that the work is perfect. For example, you can always insert data that meets the table’s requirements but is still inherently wrong (e.g. 200 is a valid integer, but it doesn’t mean that my credit limit was supposed to be 200, that depends on the surrounding application logic). Other teams become aware of the changes downstream, not synchronously upfront, and it’s instead the working group’s responsibility to both rationalize approach and create visibility into their work for other teams to engage in a non-blocking fashion. Example: Support for Financial Aggregators A concrete example of this practice at Imprint was rolling out financial aggregator support, e.g. allowing folks to connect to their Imprint powered accounts via Plaid. This has always been something folks want, but it’s particularly important in the realm of agentic commerce where more folks’ agents are analyzing their financial state for them. For this project, one of our engineering leaders (Ron), built the first pass of the feature at a low-burn while understanding the shape of the problem in a private alpha. He chatted through some of the details periodically to keep other teams aware, but it was a bit of a side project. However, once he found the full shape of the problem and had implemented a full solution, we cut the replica-lag across teams down to near-zero, identified and ran through the small number of remaining issues, and shipped it. Like many of our projects this year, it was never officially on a roadmap, and shipped a quality feature that our members have wanted for some time. How to follow the Explorer pattern The rough rules for following the Explorer pattern: Know your goal and sponsor: every initiative ultimately has to have a specific outcome it’s pursuing and a sponsor who’s bankrolling that pursuit. This doesn’t always need to be explicit, especially for smaller projects, but once a project goes beyond ~3 weeks of effort, if you can’t very explicitly identify who the stakeholder is sponsoring your project and they would not enthusiastically agree, then you are likely closer to “lost” than “exploring” Small working group is small: at most 5 people, and preferably smaller. Everyone in the group has to keep the entire project in their head for as long as possible to detect problems and opportunities Small working group is flexible: folks in small working groups have to “find a way to yes” rather than “find a way to no”. Exploring is about uncovering the fundamental shape of a problem rather than pretending we know the fundamental shape Publish progress in a public channel: explorers have to report home with the progress they are making so others are aware. This is both a Linear Project and a Slack channel. Make the narrowest viable changes to what already exists: when we introduce unnecessary changes, we invalidate others’ mental models about how the world works. When we haven’t made those changes with care, we’re not only invalidating others’ mental model, we are creating the expectation that we’ve done it very intentionally for a good reason, which has a chilling effect on others improving them later, which is very expensive, whereas the Explorer pattern depends on being as inexpensive as possible Exercise good judgment to identify reasonable hypotheses: discard bad ideas immediately, and then filter the rest by trying to implement them as quickly as possible. Once you see the shape of the implementation, you can figure out which of the remainders are interesting Hold assumptions constant to avoid getting stuck: the only way to navigate complex ambiguous problems is to hold things constant, even when you know they are imperfect. For example, to do headcount planning we have to know our revenue, to know our revenue we have to forecast it, to forecast it we have to know the day that partners will go live next year. We don’t truly know any of those things, so just anchoring on a plausible guess to unblock us is much more valuable than trying to get them accurate. A little prework is useful, but a lot is just artificial precision that’s a distraction from progress Hold space for being totally wrong: when we move fast, with low information, we always find the way out, but often it’s not the way out we anticipated when we got started. Being open to throwing it all away, and starting a second, third, fourth time Ship all the way to production behind a feature flag: features and products move fast when we get the pieces working every step from frontend to backend to data pulls. This is the first step of exploration. Just make sure it’s behind a feature flag that’s only enabled for internal folks!

14 hours ago • 2 votes
Value Creation vs Job Preservation

Comparing two different ways of work and working environments.

yesterday • 2 votes
Making a dumb TV just smart enough

I own an old, cheap TV. It has no Internet connection, no fancy smart features that make you want to install a Pi-hole, and no ask-me-again-later updates. However, it is connected to my own desktop computer through an HDMI cable, so I can watch movies and TV series from the couch. Setting it up used […] The post Making a dumb TV just smart enough appeared first on Quentin Santos.

3 days ago • 1 votes
Bikepacking across Kyushu

Five days and 540km on a bike across Kyushu, without a laptop. Notes on the peace of riding all day, convenience store dinners, and Japan's emptying countryside.

5 days ago • 1 votes
📚 BoredReading

You seem to be enjoying this.

Join free to unlock everything.

Create free account

Already have an account? Sign in