Full Width [alt+shift+f] Shortcuts [alt+shift+k]
Sign Up [alt+shift+s] Log In [alt+shift+l]
29

On general futility of political discussions with people

from Global Inequality and More 3.0 [alt+shift+b] in history

Over the years I have had political and ideological discussions with at least three groups of people and have concluded that these discussions are, almost entirely, futile in making people either see things differently, or acknowledge that others may see things differently, or -God forbid-- change their opinions however slightly. That of course opens the question how people come to hold certain political and ideological positions—since at some level they must be influenced by views of others: their parents, family, school, and even random interlocuters. I do not have a good explanation for that. I think that reading, watching, listening and thinking does lead people to form and then to change opinions but I am very sceptical that direct discussion does it. The former methods are indirect: one reads an author and finds him convincing; but if one has a discussion with somebody acknowledging that that person has produced valid arguments appears to diminish him compared to the other person, and one’s intellectual vanity does not wish to accept that. Hence, I think, discussions almost never lead toward some genuinely-felt greater similarity of opinions. They just leave the participants where they were before. Or worse, lead them further apart.
1st Oct 2023

Stay updated

Get a weekly newsletter with the top 5 articles worth reading every week.

More from Global Inequality and More 3.0

Multipolarity, neutrality and peace

Why the world peace depends on small counties’ not taking sides?

a week ago • 1 votes
Destruction and despair

A review of “A Sentimental Journey 1917-1922” by Viktor Shklovsky

13th Oct 2026 • 1 votes
Three types of literature regarding the world of AI

Economics, politics and philosophy for a new era

14th Sep 2026 • 1 votes
Ukraine, Lenin and Sultan-Galiev

Re-reading Richard Pipes’ "The Formation of the Soviet Union"

6th Aug 2026 • 1 votes
A self-absorbed giant

Dearth of Chinese lessons for the rest of the world

12th Jul 2026 • 1 votes

More in history

A weird medieval gift guide volume II

More gifts from the annals of history!

2 days ago • 1 votes
Google Chrome dev team declares bug report bankruptcy

[ I wrote this in August 2012 and then forgot about it. ] About 18 months ago I filed a report for a bug in Google Chrome. It wasn't a very important bug. I reported that when Chrome was asked to inline an image, and the image turned out to be in the obscure and seldom-used X-bitmap format, it came up as a "broken image" icon (which isn't a bug) and failed to display the alt text from the img tag (which is). a page that demonstrated the problem. To see if the problem is still present, all you have to do is click the link in the bug report. next 40,000 reports are even worse, this is the strategy to adopt. What should Chrome have done here? There is an easy thing and a hard thing. Addenda A Mastodon colleague was complaining today about a similar practice, and I wanted to refer him to this article, but couldn't because I had completely forgotten to publish it. JWZ complained about something similar in 2003.

2 days ago • 1 votes
Sun Yat-sen at 160: His Legacy in Today’s China

A full translation of Xi's speech and notes on Beijing’s reading of Sun’s legacy, national reunification and rejuvenation

a week ago • 1 votes
Research taste in history: the importance of learning Sumerian math

What I learned from a truly eccentric historian

a week ago • 1 votes
Transcript of Interview with Alexis D'Herouville on Tocqueville

An interview with Alexis D'Herouville on his ancestor, Tocqueville

a week ago • 1 votes
📚 BoredReading

You seem to be enjoying this.

Join free to unlock everything.

Create free account

Already have an account? Sign in