Full Width [alt+shift+f] Shortcuts [alt+shift+k]
Sign Up [alt+shift+s] Log In [alt+shift+l]
1

Bo Diddley

from The Universe of Discourse [alt+shift+b] in history

Bo Diddley's cover of "Sixteen Tons" sounds very much like one of my favorites, "Can't Judge A Book By Its Cover". It's interesting to compare. Thinking on that it suddenly occured to me that his name might have been a play on “diddley bow”, which is a sort of homemade one-stringed zither. The player uses a bottle as a bridge for the string, and changes the pitch by sliding the bottle up and down. When you hear about blues artists whose first guitars were homemade, this is often what was meant: it wasn't a six-string guitar, it was a diddley bow. But it's not clear that Bo Diddley play his name on the diddley bow. "Diddly" also means something insignificant or of little value, and might have been a disparaging nickname he received in his youth. (It also appears in the phrase "diddly squat"). Maybe that's also the source of the name of the diddley bow.did
3rd Mar 2026

Stay updated

Get a weekly newsletter with the top 5 articles worth reading every week.

More from The Universe of Discourse

Google Chrome dev team declares bug report bankruptcy

[ I wrote this in August 2012 and then forgot about it. ] About 18 months ago I filed a report for a bug in Google Chrome. It wasn't a very important bug. I reported that when Chrome was asked to inline an image, and the image turned out to be in the obscure and seldom-used X-bitmap format, it came up as a "broken image" icon (which isn't a bug) and failed to display the alt text from the img tag (which is). a page that demonstrated the problem. To see if the problem is still present, all you have to do is click the link in the bug report. next 40,000 reports are even worse, this is the strategy to adopt. What should Chrome have done here? There is an easy thing and a hard thing. Addenda A Mastodon colleague was complaining today about a similar practice, and I wanted to refer him to this article, but couldn't because I had completely forgotten to publish it. JWZ complained about something similar in 2003.

2 days ago • 1 votes
Recent addenda to articles 202609: Errors, omissions, and retractions

I was going to start with “it has been a while since we had one of these” but then I saw that the previous one started with “Wow, has it really been 7 months since I did one of these?” and that was in December 2023. Maybe I can make it a more regular thing. Anyway blogging itself has become a more regular thing of late so there is quite a lot to report just from last month. This article was written by an opaque and incomprehensible stoachastic process, namely me. . I have retracted this description.In 2007 I described Naomi Wolf as “very smart” now mentions that "Johnny Doc” was released from prison on the orders of Donald J. Trump.My article from January about crooked policitians and crab cakes In 2022 I published , which ended with “This article, which I wrote at 3:00 in the morning, is filled with many errors, including some that I would not have made if it had been daytime. Please disbelieve what you have read, and await a correction.” I have decided that it is uncorrectable, and retracted the whole thing.an article about the etymology of a purported Dutch phrase Dan Luu pointed out an important omission from .my July article following up on Steph Curry's 2015–16 crushing of the 3PFG record In 2021 I argued for . The coming of LLM technology has rendered my suggestion completely imprctical.an interesting replacement for the usual engineering interview process

3rd Oct 2026 • 1 votes
George Orwell's essay on the atomic bomb anticipates Nineteen Eighty-Four

Lately I've been reading Orwell's collected work from 1945–1950, which was being deaccessioned from the library. It opens with a short but fascinating essay on , published 19 October 1945. It seems clear that Orwell's thinking about this development led directly to his novel , which was written in late 1948.“You and the Atom Bomb”Nineteen Eighty-Four Orwell's initial focus is: This is important, he says, because: Obviously, the atom bomb is in the first category. Then we come to the part that is clearly the road to : Nineteen Eighty-Four By 1945 the three super-states were taking shape. Orwell writes about how in 1941 it had appeared that the Axis powers would win the war (he mentions James Burnham's ) so that Germany (not Russia) might control Europe and Asia, while Japan (not China) might control East Asia, but he said this was just a “miscalculation”:The Managerial Revolution The frozen and oppressive political milieu of is clearly laid out:Nineteen Eighty-Four was published in 1949, and Orwell died the following year after a long battle with tuberculosis. His essay on courtesy of the Orwell Foundation and Orwell's estate.Nineteen Eighty-Four“You and the Atom Bomb” is available online The question that is of most urgent interest to all of us, namely: “How difficult are these things to manufacture?” Ages in which the dominant weapon is expensive or difficult to make will tend to be ages of despotism, whereas when the dominant weapon is cheap and simple, the common people have a chance. … A complex weapon makes the strong stronger, while a simple weapon — so long as there is no answer to it — gives claws to the weak. We have before us the prospect of two or three monstrous super-states, each possessed of a weapon by which millions of people can be wiped out in a few seconds, dividing the world between them. It has been rather hastily assumed that this means bigger and bloodier wars, and perhaps an actual end to the machine civilisation. But suppose — and really this is the likeliest development — that the surviving great nations make a tacit agreement never to use the atomic bomb against one another? Suppose they only use it, or the threat of it, against people who are unable to retaliate? In that case we are back where we were before, the only difference being that power is concentrated in still fewer hands and that the outlook for subject peoples and oppressed classes is still more hopeless. More and more obviously the surface of the earth is being parcelled off into three great empires …. The haggling as to where the frontiers are to be drawn is still going on, and will continue for some years, and the third of the three super-states — East Asia, dominated by China — is still potential rather than actual. Mr H.G. Wells and others have been warning us that man is in danger of destroying himself with his own weapons…. Nevertheless, looking at the world as a whole, the drift for many decades has been not towards anarchy but towards the reimposition of slavery. We may be heading not for general breakdown but for an epoch as horribly stable as the slave empires of antiquity. … The kind of world-view, the kind of beliefs, and the social structure that would probably prevail in a state which was at once and in a permanent state of “cold war” with its neighbours.unconquerable

12th Sep 2026 • 1 votes
Seven books I keep close because I love them

The bookshelf by my elbow, the one that I can reach without getting up, has seven books on it, not necessarily the ones I look in the most, but the ones whose emanations I most hope will infuse me as I write. Roget's Thesaurus (4th edition) The one I actually refer to most often is the Harper and Row Roget's Thesaurus. I thought I had acquired this in my teens, but the note on the flyleaf says 1989. This is the fourth edition. I was very excited to get the eighth edition, which I thought I might like better, and for some time I kept them next to each other so that I could look up the same things in both, and compare. my conclusion was that while the eighth edition had more stuff in it, it wasn't stuff I needed. And it is really fat. So I have retired it to a farther shelf and will eventually get rid of it. The thesaurus is a book that is widely misunderstood. It is not, as many people mockingly imagine, just a compendium of synonyms, and its correct and intended use is not to replace common words with more impressive-sounding ones. just as the correct use of a screwdriver is not to scrape the veneer off of an expensive cabinet. “Thesaurus” means “storehouse" or “treasure room”. Roget's idea, similar to that of John Wilkins before him, was to classify everything in the world into a hierarchy, in this case a hierarchy with a thousand divisions. At the top level the divisions are grouped into "Abstract concepts", "Space”, “Physics”, “Matter”, “Sensation” and so on. Then under “abstract concepts” there are subclasses, of which subclass VI is “Time”, subdivided into five smaller sections: A. Absolute time At the next level down, section (1)(VI)(B) is divided into: §116. Priority Roget's idea is that if you are thinking or writing about time, and specifically about how it goes by, you will leaf through those sections for inspiration, not to find a more pompous way of expressing something you have already written, but to refine your own idea of what it is you wanted to express. Perhaps you are trying to say that one event followed immediately after another. You might look at “§117 posteriority (later time)” which mentions “ensue”, “consequence”, “aftermath”, and “subsequent” — not synonyms, but related aspects of similar concepts, worth more or less consideration depending on what you are trying to emphasize. §117 will also suggest common phrases like “step into the shoes of” — not a synonym by any means, but a related idea. This is probably not what you wanted in this case, but it in another it might be just the thing, and in any case it might give you a bright idea. If nothing in section 117 seems suitable, it is right next to “§116 priority”, and you might discover that instead of saying that the second event followed immediately after the first, you would rather say that the first immediately preceded the second. Or perhaps you realize, looking at “§118 Simultaneity”, that what you really want to say is that the two event were not quite simultaneous. Or perhaps, finding your way to “§131 Earliness” and “§132 Lateness” you realize that your meaning would be more clearly expressed if you said that the second event was a little tardy, or that the first event was premature. Looking through the index for “immediately” you will see that the index distinguishes several senses of “immediate”: are you trying to suggest intantaneity, or continuity, or haste, or promptness, or punctuality? And in this way the book helps you refine your understanding of what you were trying to say. One can use the thesaurus for more concrete tasks. Perhaps I am trying to remember a word, but I can't quite put my finger on it. I know it it is not “coexisting”, but is something like it. I can look up “coexisting” in the index, and it will take me to “§118 Simultaneity” where I find “contemporaneous”… aha, that's what I was looking for! The really important thing about the thesaurus is this large-scale organizing principle, which puts related ideas near one another. Note that none of this works for someone who doesn't know what the words actually mean. All that person can do with the thesaurus is to replace one wrong word with another one, more or less at random. Effective tool use requires skill and training, and careful thought. An online version would be more convenient, but again, it wouldn't have the same stuff and I am very attached to the one I have. My banishment of the 8th edition left a lot of space on the shelf, some of which I have filled with an anthology of the prose of Sir Thomas Browne. I think this will be healthful and inspiring for me, especially if I remember to take it up and thumb through it from time to time. The Prose of Sir Thomas Browne One recurring theme on this blog since the very earliest days has been the writers of the English Baroque period. In 2008 I wrote: [Browne] is witty, and learned, and wise, and humane, and to read his books is to feel that you are in the company of this witty, learned, wise, humane man, one of the best men that the English Renaissance has to offer, and that you are profiting thereby. His work was also a favorite of Jorge Luis Borges', in case you consider that a recommendation. Browne has shown up here a number of times, although not so much as he should have, because I started the blog the year after I was on my big Thomas Browne kick. One reason I have put this book next to my elbow is that I hope it will spark a new Browne kick. (I wrote in 2006 “I'm sure I will return someday”, and it is long past time for that return.) My favorite book by Browne is his Pseudodoxia Epidemica, which is a compilation of stuff that people in 1646 believed that Browne thought was probably wrong. I wrote about that in come detail in 2008 although I didn't get around to publishing it until 2020. And somehow the other three articles I was writing about this have never seen the light of day. One is about his discussion of whether John the Baptist actually ate locusts or whether they were locust beans or something else. Browne is firmly on the side of it being actual locusts, as am I. My unpublished article says: Chester Brown's version of the gospels makes it clear that John was a crazy old bug-gobbler. Panels from Yummy Fur #17, page 15, by Chester Brown. Also Sir Thomas comes up in connection with whether snails have eyes in their horns — a rare example where he was wrong, and for a dumb reason: If we concede they have two eyes, we must alse grant, they have no lesse than four… And therefore if they have two eyes, they have also four, which will be monstrous, and beyond the affirmation of any. Browne seems to be noping out of the very idea of four-eyed snails, and therefore that they must have none at all. In a later edition of the book, he changed his mind, which is to his credit. He had a thoughtful and well-informed opinion about whether Pythagoras forbade his followers from eating beans, supposedly because he thought they contained the souls of the dead. (Browne says the former is true, but not the latter.) I have trouble connecting with the thinkers of the Middle Ages. Their thinking seems to me to be frightened, so overcautious, so cramped and circumscribed, I can't read it without sadness for the way that medieval Christianity strangled the human spirit for so long. But in the early Renaissance there is a flowering of a joyfully brave willingness to try to understand the world, and to follow any inquiry, no matter how extravagant or ridiculous. The whole idea of God has transformed, changed from something constricting to something empowering. The world before belonged to God, and humans were in it only grudgingly and on promise of good behavior. But when the Renaissance started, the world became a beautiful gift, in which humans had been placed to honor God by admiring and marveling at his creation. This admiration and marvel, the willingness to follow any path to understanding, is how I want to be about knowledge and how I hope I am. Reading Browne, I always feel like he and I would have gotten along well, and that that is one of the best parts of myself. Boccaccio's Decameron The story of the Decameron is this: It is 1348, and Venice is devastated by Black Plague. Nothing can be done, despair is everywhere, and there are not enough left living to bury the dead. So ten young people, still healthy, decide to turn their backs on suffering and quit town. They take provisions and servants, retire to the country, and try to forget the horrors they have seen. There they spend the time feasting, walking in the gardens, playing chess, and, once a day, for ten days, they meet, choose a theme, and then each of them tells a story on the theme. I explained this once to a friend who said “That sounds cool, when was it written?” I said “In 1348!” It is one of the two great works of classical Italian literature, the other of course being Dante. Dante is solidly medieval, hierarchical, doctrinaire, and obsessed with a God who is supposedly loving but doesn't seem to know how to show it. That was in 1308 or so, and then, only a few decades later, we have the Decameron which could not be more different. It is about people, doing people things in the real world, eating, drinking, singing, arguing, and making love. God is present, but not oppressive. He has sent a terrible plague for who knows what reason, but rather than submit to it the characters of the Decameron try to take practical steps to make the best of it. There is a story in the Decameron for every mood, usually more than one. Some are sad, some romantic, some funny and salacious. Dioneo is exempt from following the daily theme and usually has a story that is more or less dirty. My favorite story is probably the one about the cross-dressing English princess, or perhaps the one about how young Caterina wanted to sleep on the balcony so that she could hear the nightingale, which I find very sweet. But the funniest one is about the abbess who is called out of her cell one night to berate a nun for having her lover stay over, and who doesn't realize that in her hurry she has put her own lover's trousers on her head instead of her wimple. I have several different Decamerons, but this copy is the Cormac Ó Cuilleanáin translation, which has made several previous appearances here: On the word “squillions”. Following up a chance encounter in the Oxford English Dictionary is what led me to discover the Decameron in the first place The phrase “two-bit huckster” “soup-guzzling pie-muncher” “soup-guzzling pie-muncher” again There's also an unpublished blog article inviting me to look into this passage: Messer Lotto Gualandi gave him a daughter of his, Bartolomea by name, one of the fairest and handsomest young ladies of Pisa — although most of the females from that benighted town look like tarantulas. The J.M. Rigg translation says “spotted lizards”. This is closer to the original Italian, which is lucertole verminare, literally small wormy lizards. I have my doubts about the desirability of living to be a thousand years old, but if I do decide to do it, one reason will certainly be that I will need the time to learn Medieval Italian and translate the Decameron. From Frege to Gödel, edited by van Heijenoort This is a collection of the most important papers in mathematical logic from the time of Frege (who, I have written before, was responsible for kicking the field of logic out of its medieval period into the modern world) to Gödel (who of course spoiled everything). In between these van Heijenoort hits all the most important ideas, starting with Frege's explanation of Begriffsschrift, which is wacky and weird and which didn't catch on except it kind of did and it still underlies half of mathematical logic and which is the prototype for many of the symbols we still use. After this there is Russell's tragic correspondence with Frege in which he pointed out, too late, that Frege's foundational theory didn't work. The book reprints Peano's original description of the Peano numbers, perhaps the most successful single mathematical theory of all time. The book includes Zermelo's proof of Zermelo's theorem that every set can be well-ordered, and Ackermann's discovery of Ackermann's function, which demonstrated the not every computable function is primitive recursive. The book has Russell on type theory and early work by Kolmogorov and Brouwer on the origin of intuitionism. (Heyting is missing.) Van Heijenoort has come up here when I wanted to quote from Schönfinkel's paper about the SKI-calculus, Wiener's paper inventing the ordered pair, and implicitly in probably a dozen other math and logic articles here over the years. The book is on my shelf because I refer to it pretty often, but also because I can usually find something interesting just by thumbing through it. For example, these remarks by Thoralf Skolem about the futility of deriving induction from set-theoretic foundations. Bonus trivia: Van Heijenoort was the personal secretary of Leon Trotsky, and while he was accompanying Trotsky during the latter's exile in Mexico, he was one of Frida Kahlo's lovers. Orbis Sensualium Pictis (English edition), Johannes Comenius I adore this book. My heart swells with love when I think of it. I don't have a blog article about it and there is a story behind that. In 2018 I went to a conference in Cleveland and my hotel was in a building that had formerly been the Cleveland Department of Education. This one has two big murals, one depicting “The Progress of Education”: I planned to write a blog article about these people. It's clear who some of them are. For example, Moses is easy to recognize at lower right, because of the glowing horns, and Confucius is next to him. Some people I was familiar with once they were identified for me: the red-haired guy second from right in the back row is Friedrich Fröbel, who I knew; his “gifts” are a forerunner of the Montessori materials. But in doing the research I got to the bearded hat-wearing dude topmost on the right side and completely fell off the bus, because that is Johann Comenius who is famous because he wrote one of the most marvelous and enchanting books I've ever read, the Orbis Pictus. I have to resist the temptation to say too much, because Orbis Pictus derailed the article about “The Progress of Education”, it then derailed its own article which has been in progress for eight years, and if I let it it will derail this article too, because every time I pick up Orbis Pictus I forget whatever I was doing and I am lost in the pages with a happy and innocent smile on my face. I'm going to precommit to writing only one paragraph about this incredible book. It was the first illustrated children's book published in Europe, in 1658, and it was an immediate hit, being translated from German into English the following year, then into French, Italian, and many other languages. It swept the continent because everyone loved it. Most of the book follows this pattern: there will be an engraved illustration, depicting some aspect of ordinary human activity, such as (I open it up to a random page) “Tame Foul” (that is, “fowl”): Items of interest in the engraving are annotated with numbers, and the facing page explains the illustration, one item at a time: The Cock 1 (which croweth in a morning), hath a comb, 2. In a second column to the right of this is the same text, but in Latin, so that while the reader is learning about tame fowl, they are also learning Latin: Gallus 1. (qui manè cantat) habet Cristam, 2. The prose is limpid, gentle, pithy, and direct. It hits the important points of interest, invites questions, and ends before anyone can get bored. There are pages on anatomy, butchery, feasting, winemaking, various principal virtues, family trees, cities, burials, ships, wells, horology, amphibians. Now I will reluctantly put it down, rather than leaving this article unfinished as I have so many before. The Bible (New International Version, large print) This of course is the cornerstone of Western culture and no well-educated person can be without a knowledge of what is in it. It is full of great wisdom and great stories, and also cruelty, evil lies, and reminders that the world now is in many ways better than it was because people are better. I would like to understand the world I live in, and there is no way to understand 21st-century America without understanding the Bible. The NIV is not the most poetical translation, but it is clear, modern, and accurate. (I got it on the recommendation of Sterling Hanenkampf. Thanks, Sterling!) In former times I had a collection of Bibles but this is the only one that remains. I even got rid of my old King James, since office space is precious and I have had a digital copy on my computer since the early 1990s. I find that most of my articles mentioning the Bible are unpublished for some reason. It comes up a bit in connection with Ploni Almoni, and in passing in many other places. One of the unfinished articles is a series of notes on the theme of Jesus's admonition “Do not put the Lord your God to the test” (Matthew 4:7) and its relationship to a lot of other things like lightning rods, Christian Science (not Christian science), how Larry Wall became a computer programmer, Pikuach nefesh, and the story of the old lady who refused to evacuate from her house during a flood. It'll be epic if I ever finish it, but I probably won't. Another incomplete one is about the incredible story of Samson and Delilah: She asks him flat out: [Judges 16:6] Tell me the secret of your great strength, and how you can be tied up and subdued. Instead of just telling her to fuck off, Samson lies: [16:7] If anyone ties me with seven fresh bowstrings that have not been dried, I'll become as weak as any other man. The Philistines bring her bowstrings and she tries it that night, but Samson snaps the bowstrings as easily as a piece of string snaps when it comes close to a flame. … Then it goes as before! He tells her a different lie, knowing full well that she will betray him, and she does betray him, and he makes a fool of her again! (16:11–12) Okay, that was fun. Let's do it again! (16:13–14) After several repetitions of this, Samson decides that being shaved, blinded and killed will be less exasperating than listening to any more of Delilah's nagging. I read once that the whole point of the book of Judges is that the people in it are all terrible, they are all far from the path of righteousness, and so you definitely shouldn't act like them. I don't know if that interpretation is correct, but it is certainly true that the people in it are all terrible. The Belles Heures of Duc de Berry This book turned up in one of my very first blog articles, on abbreviations in medieval manuscripts, although I didn't know it at the time. In my teens, on a visit to the Metropolitan Museum of Art, I picked up a print of this: Then I carried it with me for the next forty years, eventually framing it and hanging it up, and it is hanging in my house now. Many years after, when I was still on Twitter and Twitter was still fun, I subscribed to a daily feed from the Met, and one day they tweeted this page, or perhaps another page from the same book, stylistically similar enough that I recognized it immediately. They said where it was from: it's the Belles Heures, a “book of hours”, which tells the reader when to pray and how, and which days are sacred to which saints. Very wealthy people had super-fancy ones made from the very best materials, with illustrations by the very best craftsmen. The Duc de Berry was so wealthy that he had more than one, as I found out when I accidentally ordered and received the Tres Riches Heures. But I got the one I wanted eventually. The Duc de Berry book is by Millard Meiss and Elizabeth H. Beatson, and alternates beween the magnificent color plates and prose discussing each one. From the inscription on the page above I had been able to figure out that this was John the Baptist (see previous article), and the authors aren't sure who the other two people are, but they did at least tell me that John was the Duc de Berry's name-saint. (Funny how John keeps popping up, isn't it?) More recently I had another very similar Internet revelation. I've had this framed postcard hanging up for many years: and thanks to a recent Mastodon toot by Cam Larios, I found out that it is from the “Black Hours” of the Morgan Library. #8? The banishment of the very large Roget 8th edition has left enough space on the shelf for an eighth book. I took a quick look around my office to see if there was anything else that wanted to fill that space, but nothing volunteered. (Actually I think Tristan Needham's Visual Complex Analysis might be waving to me from across the room.) Other stuff There are other things in the photo that should not be on this shelf and I don't know why they are: A packet of googly eye stickers Glass and ceramic coasters that I don't use because my coffee cup is always on my electric mug warmer A small audio speaker that might or might not work A boxful of 8mm-helical scan backup tape from the 1990s A pair of old laptop 2.5-inch hard disks that I hope to someday get the data out of A set of Korean playing cards The shelf is like my brain, I guess, full of stuff, and and what's in it doesn't always make sense or go together with the other stuff.

3rd Aug 2026 • 1 votes
Starting to understand epsilon-zero

This post is going to be about what infinite ordinal numbers are, and about is in particular. I had a brainwave a while back (18 months now, wow, I have definitely not been blogging enough) and suddenly understood much better than I did before. I have several related ideas here and I am going to try to write one blog post about each of them, instead of one gigantic blog post about all of them together that I never finish. I really like the ordinal numbers. For some reason I was repeatedly exposed to the infinite cardinals as a child and, while they are pleasingly mysterious, they're also somewhat uninteresting because they have no internal structure, they are just bignesses. It's super cool that there is more than one possible bigness of an infinite set, of course, but sets can have all sorts of interesting structure, and looking just at the bigness ignores all that. The ordinals are much more satisfying, and also I feel that they are more like numbers. This post explains how they work and introduces the interesting ordinal . (I wrote an article a while back about how, when your twelve-year-old asks “what is infinity” you should answer as if they had asked “what is ”. Later I found out that Joel Hamkins recommended the same strategy, and I still stand by it.) What we're doing The idea behind the ordinals is that we want to define something like the “natural” numbers , where each number has a successor and there is a less-than relation. But we want to do it in the context of elementary set theory, which is simpler. Extremely simple, in fact. What is set theory? I don't know how intelligible this article will be if you don't already know, but I am going to try to explain it as briefly as possible. People who already know what means can skip to the next section. In set theory, the only kind of object is a “set”, which is like a featureless bag of things, which are called elements. What kind of things? We don't care, that's not part of the model. The only properties a set has are which things are in the bag. It doesn't make sense to ask what color a set is or whather it is a citizen of Belgium; sets don't have colors, they aren't citizens of anywhere, and they don't have any other extrinsic properties. The only kind of question you can ask is about a set is: Is this thing in that set ? When it is, we write , and when it isn't we write . When a set contains the things and , and nothing else, we write it as $$ \{ p, q, r\} $$ so for example but There is one special set called the “empty set” that has nothing in it at all; it's written . The one other piece of set theory you need to know for this article is that if you have two or more sets, you can combine them into a single set that contains everything that the original sets did. This is called the union of the sets. When combining two sets and , we write for their union. For example: $$ \{\text{tea}, \text{coffee}\} \cup \{\text{mango}, \text{octopus}\} = \{ \text{tea}, \text{coffee}, \text{mango}, \text{octopus} \} $$ There is a lot more than that to set theory but that is the basic idea and I think it's enough to get pretty far in this article. To define numbers in the context of elementary set theory means that we want to find sets that we can interpret as numbers, and a way to interpret arithmetic and such as being operations on these sets. We want to show that those sets can be made to behave the way we expect numbers to behave, and that we can prove that the arithmetic operations have the properties that we expect numbers to have. For numbers, it's true that , and we want to be sure that, whatever we decide that means for sets, and whatever sets we've chosen to stand in for and , we should still have . Understanding when we can model a complicated system in terms of a simpler one, and how to do that, is one of the main concerns of mathematics. Set theory is just about the simplest system there is, so mathematics spends a lot of time trying to interpret various complicated systems in terms of set theory. Less-than Numbers have a less-than relation , and elementary set theory has only one relation, , so it makes sense to try to use that for less-than, and see if it works. We’ll say that if and are sets that represent numbers, then means the same as . We want to be transitive. That is if and then we should also have . If we're taking to be synonymous with , then this means that if and are sets that represent numbers, and if and , then we should also have . This is kind of a weird situation. It means that is not a set of fish or carrots, it means that is a set of sets. And it means any element of any of ’s sets is also an element of itself. When this happens we say that the set is transitive, using the word “transitive” analogously to the way we do what we say that is transitive. Transitivity puts fairly strict constraints on what a set can be like. There are lots of sets, but relatively few of them are transitive. Here are some examples of transitive sets, and the numbers they represent: $$ \begin{align*} 0 &= \{\}\\ 1&=\{0\} \\ \end{align*} $$ Since we are using here as just another way to write the empty set , we could have written instead of . They mean exactly the same. But I feel that the nested curly braces quickly get confusing and don't really contribute to understanding. Still, remember that when we write the symbols , and so on, we're not using them in their usual sense of numbers. Rather, we are talking about these particular transitive sets. The next one is: $$ \begin{align*} 2 & = \{0, 1\} \\ \end{align*} $$ Since and the is an abbreviation for the set $$ \{\{\}, \{\{\}\} \}. $$ I hope you can see why I want to avoid the raw curly-brace notation. Continuing, we have: $$ \begin{align*} 3 & = \{0, 1, 2\}\\ 4 & = \{0, 1, 2, 3\}\\ \vdots\\ 9 & = \{0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8\},\\ \vdots\\ 53 &= \{0, 1, 2, \dots, 52\}\\ \vdots \end{align*} $$ And so on. These sets are all transitive. For example, and and sure enough, also. This isn’t trivial: Not every set of numbers is transitive. For example is not a transitive set because and but . We'll say that an ordinal number is a set that is transitive, and whose elements are also all transitive. All the sets in the list above are examples. There are transitive sets that aren't ordinals, but we're not interested in them in this article, because they aren't number-like in the same way. This identification of numbers as theser particular sets does also make behave like the less-than relation in the way we wanted. For example, we have because , but not vice versa, it's not true that because . Technically this definition has a lot to recommend it. It’s extremely simple, which makes it easy to work with, and many natural theorems are easily proved. For example, when dealing with familiar numbers, it’s always false that , for any . We'd like to able to prove the analogous thing for our synthetic sets-as-numbers. If we can’t (or worse, if we can prove the opposite) then our model is missing something important (or worse, it’s just wrong). Well, by our definition of less-than, simply means , which is false because has no elements, and that's the proof that is false. Successorship Another thing we need from numbers is a successor operation: each number should be followed by another, different one, and it should be possible to calculate which one. This has been recognized since the 19th century as the most important organizing principle that the natural numbers have. It’s is one of the few foundational things that almost every mathematician not only accepts but is happy with. If is some transitive set, we should be able to identify another, different transitive set that we can designate as the successor of , the number that follows in the sequence of numbers. It’s not hard to show that if is transitive then so is $$ T\cup \{T\} $$ See how it works when : the successor of is $$ 2\cup\{2\} = \{0, 1\}\cup\{2\} = \{0,1,2\} = 3 $$ as we would hope. Limits This gets us the numbers, as we wanted, and we could go on from here to explain how and work and so on, but today we are going a different direction. It turns out that if we add one more ingredient we get a lot more than just familiar numbers. There’s one other way of making an ordinal number out of smaller ordinal numbers. If is any family of transitive sets, then their union, the set that contains everything that is in any of them, is an ordinal also. When the family has a largest element , (typically because it’s a finite family) then the union is not anything new, it’s just again. For example . But if the family of transitive sets has no largest element, we do get something new. In particular, the union $$ \omega = 0\cup 1\cup 2\cup\dots $$ is an ordinal number. By constructing the numbers as transitive sets, we got what we wanted: the finite ordinals behave just like numbers. But if we also consider infinite ordinals, we get infinite numbers like that behave, in some ways, like bigger siblings of the numbers. participates very nicely in less-than comparisons and minimum and maximum operations, and somewhat nicely in addition and multiplication. is an ordinal number but not a familiar one. Under our definition of as a synonym for , every finite number is less than ; there's no familiar number that behaves that way. It’s different from finite numbers in another way also: except for , each finite number is a successor of some other finite number and so has a predecessor, whereas is not a successor of anything and has no predecessor. Ordinals like that are not successors are called limit ordinals. Every ordinal has a successor, and is an ordinal set, so it has one, usually written as , which is the next ordinal after . Then there follow , and the union of all of these is the set $$ \{0, 1, 2, \dots, \omega, \omega+1, \omega+2,\dots\} $$ which is called —still an ordinal. After these come , and eventually . Then after a long series of things like $$\omega^2·17 + \omega·39+117$$ comes , then including an infinite ordinal for every polynomial involving , and then the union of all those, . The series continues — it continues forever, we can always find a bigger transitive set — with things like $$ \omega^{\omega^{\omega^{53}·3+11}·2+\omega·19+1}·7 + \omega^{\omega^{17}·143+53}·12 + \omega^{99938}·12712781 + \omega^{99936}·12712781 +\omega+ 2 $$ where it’s like a polynomial in , except that the exponents don’t have to be finite numbers, they can be other super-polynomials in whose exponents don’t have to be finite. And then, after all of these, the limit of this mind-boggling sequence, is the ordinal called $$ \epsilon_0 $$ It’s just gotten too complicated to express with regular mathematical expressions involving . It transpires that this is the smallest ordinal satisfying the property that $$ x = \omega^x $$ This is the thing I have finally been able to get my head around, a little. The next article will explain how.

10th Jul 2026 • 1 votes

More in history

¡A la Huelga!: A Full Report on Spain’s General Strike from Vallekas, Madrid, and Barcelona

In response to the violent eviction of Maricarmen Abascal, a disabled 87-year-old woman, people around Spain poured into the streets and set up encampments in the plazas in a movement against evictions and gentrification. On November 11, a general strike took place throughout the country—the first in fourteen years. Here, we present accounts of the events from the vantage points of Madrid and Barcelona. This is a valuable document for all who seek to build the power to defend our communities. The View from Madrid We sit in a loosely arranged circle in a local social center run by a trade union. It’s just past midnight. When the clock strikes 12, marking the beginning of Wednesday, November 11, we erupt into cheers. Spain’s first general strike in 14 years is underway. 4.5 million people mobilized 1340 committees across the Spanish state 108 cities mobilized 4 million+ leaflets distributed 600,000+ posters put up “General Strike for Housing” website The building opened at 8 pm on Tuesday; it will stay open until 8 pm on Wednesday, with a room designated for strikers to take naps. People mill about, preparing food for our late dinner, drying wet clothing with a hairdryer that someone thought to bring from home. Some catch up with old friends, as the social center has become a gathering place for all in the area who need it. Others sign up to take shifts making coffee, preparing food, and protecting the space over the hours ahead. We are Vallekanos, some by birth, others more recent transplants. Vallecas, known as Vallekas to many, is an urban area of Madrid so large that it was divided into two districts (Puente de Vallecas and Villa de Vallecas). The area is an epicenter of anti-fascist working-class resistance in Spain’s capital. After Maricarmen was evicted in September and the general strike was announced in October, local organizations and social movements in the districts came together to help organize for the strike. Similar convergences have taken place in thousands of localities around Spain. “It’s syndicalist terrorism.” —Isabel Díaz Ayuso, right-wing President of the “Madrid Community” The enthusiasm that fills this social center on the eve of the general strike flows from the same energy that erupted in millions of Spaniards on the day that Maricarmen Abascal, an 87-year-old woman, was evicted from her home of 70 years in Madrid. Something clicked in the collective consciousness of the country at that moment. The percentage of Spain’s population that lives as tenants has risen steadily over the last few decades, reaching 25%, and recently, rents have skyrocketed. All of us have heard the horror stories. A coworker who lives in a village a hundred kilometers away because they couldn’t afford housing near the office. Families with children who are forced to live in a single sub-letted room. Residents of protected housing who were evicted after their homes were sold to ruthless investment funds. A memorial to Maricarmen a few steps away from her home. Thanks to years of hard work by grassroots housing movements across the country, a voice has emerged to connect these struggles. The Sindicato de Inquilinas (“Tenant’s Union”) has become a household name, appearing day after day in the news and on social media. The Union has shown the country that it is neither normal nor right that decent, stable housing has become increasingly impossible to find in this country, and the opportunity to become a homeowner even more so. The Union has exposed these struggles as the product of a deliberate political and financial strategy perpetrated by the wealthy. The Union has developed a powerful architecture of local assemblies, which made it possible to channel this collective outrage into a call for a general strike. What follows is a local report and analysis from the districts of Vallekas and the city of Madrid as a whole, tracing the efforts leading up to the strike and the events of the day itself. It Was About Time for a Strike! As we reported last month, the current housing crisis in Spain had been approaching a breaking point in the months leading up to Maricarmen’s eviction. In Madrid, rental prices have risen 50% over the past five years, and many in the city find themselves forced to spend upwards of 70% of their monthly salaries on rent. In 2025, there were nearly 25,000 evictions nationwide, 74.6% of which were due to non-payment of rent. Maricarmen had struggled for years alongside the Sindicato de Inquilinas de Madrid against the investment fund that had become the owner of her home; that fund, Urbagestión, had raised her rent by an exorbitant amount that she could not pay. Her eviction on September 23 became a symbol of the ruthless cruelty of these “vulture funds,” as they’re popularly known, and of the unsustainable conditions that tenants live under nationwide. The Sindicato de Inquilinas organized a mass demonstration through the center of Madrid on September 26 to protest against Maricarmen’s eviction, demanding “houses for living in, not for speculation.” Some 300,000 people attended. As they reached Madrid’s House of Representatives, some participants realized that the demonstration needed to go further. Protesters immediately began setting up tents in the nearby Puerta del Sol, the square in the heart of Madrid. Fifteen years earlier, that square had been the home to the 15M encampment, one of most important manifestations of popular resistance in Spain’s recent history. “We’re not going to stop, because Madrid has finally woken up. We won’t let them keep ruling over our lives,” proclaimed Valeria Racu, one of the spokespersons of the Sindicato de Inquilinas, at the encampment that evening. By September 30, there were 1248 tents at the camp. The encampment at Puerta del Sol. The Sindicato de Inquilinas proved to be extremely adept at leveraging the momentum of the events following Maricarmen’s eviction to force the government and the rest of Spain’s civil society into action. Formed in 2017, the Sindicato adopted the underlying organizing principle of sindicalismo de base, grassroots unionism. Although it is not an explicitly anarchist organization, the group has acknowledged that they are heavily influenced by the revolutionary anarcho-syndicalism of the Confederación Nacional del Trabajo [CNT]. Working horizontally through local assemblies and neighborhood nodos (nodes), all members become involved from their very first meeting in helping each other to face their housing issues. Direct action is at the core of their practice. In one of their strategies, Nos Quedamos (“We’re staying put”), tenants facing rent hikes stay in their homes and continue paying their old rent. Another approach, Bloques en Lucha (“Resistance buildings”), takes the offensive by reaching out to the tenants of buildings owned by the same landlord to help them organize against potential housing abuses before they happen. Thus attuned to the growing popular will for change, the Confederación de Sindicatos de Inquilinas (Confederation of Tenants’ Unions), representing 21 cities throughout Spain, presented a proposal for a “Maricarmen Decree.” They advanced a list of measures to tackle the housing crisis and demanded that the government’s Council of Ministers vote to approve it the following week. The Confederación also urged the country’s major labor unions, the CCOO (Comisiones Obreras) and UGT (Unión General de Trabajadores), to call for a national general strike if the decree was voted down, adding in their press conference that “it would no longer make sense for the government to remain in power” if the measures were not approved. The encampment in the Puerta del Sol joined with other activist groups and the rest of the housing movement to intensify critical pressure on the government. A protest sign reading “Vulture funds, get out of our neighborhoods!” But the government of Socialist Party Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez once again proved itself to be a snake disguised as a paragon of European leftism. It accepted the proposed decree, with one small caveat: it split the proposal into two decrees, separating the fifth and most revolutionary measure, indefinite contracts, into a separate decree. This was intended to ensure that his government could get credit for “fixing” the housing crisis without upsetting capital markets too much. In any case, while the Council of Ministers approved both decrees, both failed to pass in Congress. The rejection of the decrees set off a rapid series of events. On October 5, Sánchez called for a snap general election on November 29. On October 7, alongside the leftist labor unions CGT, Comisiones de Base [Co.bas], and Solidaridad Obrera and the majority labor unions CCOO and UGT, the Confederación de Sindicatos de Inquilinas declared that the general nationwide 24-hour strike would take place on November 11. That same day, Maricarmen passed away. She had been taken to the hospital when she was evicted two weeks earlier. “Fight for what is yours” was the message she left for the movement. Maricarmen at a housing protest in May 2026. The November 11 general strike was the first in the country in 14 years, though a major feminist strike took place in 2018. Significantly, it was the first general strike since Spain’s transition to democracy in which the country’s largest mainstream labor unions did not play a central role. The Confederación de Sindicatos de Inquilinas had been working on plans for a general strike since 2025 alongside the country’s combative and alternative labor unions and in conversation with stateless nationalist trade unions (in Catalonia, Basque Country, Galicia, and other regions where people seek autonomy) and mainstream labor unions. The support of the CCOO and UGT was critical to convening a mass general strike, since their combined membership totals over two million workers. However, these are reformist unions that have historically functioned as state proxies, falling in line with the government and the interests of business leaders and suppressing real change. They were ultimately forced to agree to call for the general strike by the massive mobilization from below. During the weeks leading up to the strike, they demonstrated their uselessness by doing the bare minimum—and in many cases nothing at all—to organize their workplaces. These reformist unions treated the strike as something like a campaign event for Sánchez´s government. Regardless of the union bureaucrats, the real work was taking place in workplaces, neighborhoods, hospitals, schools, universities, and on the street. A massive grassroots movement across all sectors of society mobilized to spread the word about the demands of the strike, talking to people about how the housing crisis was affecting them and urging them to walk out of their workplaces on November 11. The specific demands varied from one group to the next, but the most common demands included: Cutting and capping rent prices by linking them to personal income; Prohibiting residential properties from being used for financial speculation and expropriating the homes bought up by vulture funds and banks; Putting an end to evictions and establishing indefinite rental contracts; Combatting racism in the housing sector; A mass expansion of the public housing stock through expropriation, a wealth tax, and the creation of publicly owned construction companies; and Increasing salaries, pensions, and public services. Over 1340 local strike committees took part in this mass mobilization in city neighborhoods and villages across the country. It cannot be overstated how diverse those committees were. They brought together participants from neighborhood associations, public education and activist groups, alternative labor unions, anti-racist organizations, the LGBTQ+ and feminist movements, migrant associations, anarchist collectives, socialist groups, the ecological movement, and squatter collectives along with the wide array of initiatives connected to the housing movement and representatives from left-wing political parties. This made it possible to organize the strike in a decentralized way, preventing any particular group or sector from exerting disproportionate control over the course of events. Conflicts over predominance did occur in some committees, of course. But the underlying structure proved to be highly effective at distributing power horizontally while organizing nationwide for the strike. Thanks to the local infrastructure that these groups had built over years of movement work, there were already many different places to organize in each locality and many other sectors of the community with whom it was possible to forge alliances. And since each of these participating collectives worked to promote the strike on their own, the committees had a massive amplifying effect, providing a forum for a wide range of movements to engage in dialogue and unite their efforts. Most of the committees across the country met weekly in local social centers, with some dividing further into working groups focusing directly on communications or specific actions. One noteworthy tool that the Sindicato de Inquilinas created to help organize strike actions was Toka, a mobile and web app that presented users with a map of their area, showing all of the activities that were being organized, from information tables in public squares and committee assemblies to banner-making sessions and creative actions to capture the public’s attention. This helped members of the public to get involved in the pre-strike activities even if they didn’t belong to any particular group or union or hadn’t been able to attend local assemblies due to time constraints. It facilitated the organization of more actions by making it easy for those who had previously not been connected to collaborate easily. While Toka was only one tool among many used in the weeks leading up to the strike, 2328 activities were organized on this platform alone. Vallekas Gets Ready “Us old ladies have to support all of this, because I’m a Vallekana, you know what I mean? No one can tell me anything about Vallekas, because I’m a Vallekana, and there are really good people living here, hard-working people… They’re destroying the Social Security system. Can you believe I’ve been waiting to see a doctor for 25 days? But it’s not the doctor’s fault… how could it be their fault? They’re cutting their throats, just like the señoritas [public school teachers]. So us old ladies, we also support you.” —Juani, a proud Vallekana, speaking with activists in a public square The Vallekas area of Madrid has long been a site of working-class resistance in the Spanish capital. A 30-minute walk from the center of Madrid, the districts provided a home for migrants moving to the city from impoverished areas of Andalusia and Extremadura in the 1950s and 1960s and, more recently, for immigrants from Latin America and Morocco. For a large part of the 20th century, the Vallekas area existed mostly as a slum, ignored by the local government and lacking many of the basic public resources people need to live. Residents thus had to—and still have to—rely on each other to get by, and must fight for the changes needed to improve their communities. Spain’s first neighborhood association was founded here in 1968; over the past half century, residents have waged powerful struggles to demand resources such as public schools, sewage systems, and paved roads. In one action in 1985, 14,000 residents formed a human chain across the area’s two districts to demand a Metro line. Vallekanos fighting for basic resources. The legacy of this spirit of resistance lives on as a core part of the local identity. The area’s slums have gradually been replaced by newer residences, roads, parks, schools, and businesses. While it now exists as an extension of the capital city, Vallekas still faces problems that the local right-wing government refuses to address. We are writing this text from Vallekas; from this vantage point, we can offer a more detailed perspective on the general strike of November 11. One of the most critical issues facing Vallekas is the looming spectre of gentrification. While many people once considered the area impossible to gentrify, as Madrid has become more and more expensive, both tenants and speculators have expanded outward from the center. Tourist apartments have begun popping up in the unlikeliest of places. Banks that had previously financed social housing have sold entire buildings to vulture funds, resulting in countless evictions, and what was once a relatively affordable area to live in has begun pushing out its longtime residents. In addition, a significant proportion of these districts’ population are immigrants. Given that 70% of the immigrant population in Spain rents their home, they are disproportionately affected by the current crisis. David, a tenant of Caixabank’s former social housing, which was sold to vulture funds, thanking the activists who came out to support him on the morning of his eviction. Meetings of different housing rights groups overflowed throughout the districts in the days following Maricarmen’s eviction. One of the oldest housing rights groups in Vallekas is the Platform for People Affected by Mortgages (PAH), although today their activities are not limited to helping those affected by mortgages. A Sindicato de Inquilinas node joined them in the area over the past year. Large numbers of local residents turned out to Vallekas’ united strike committee following the call for the general strike. The participants divided the expansive area of both Puente and Villa de Vallekas into neighborhoods, streets, and commercial areas. Each association or collective in the committee took responsibility for a different area, pasting posters, handing out leaflets, talking to businesses, and taking responsibility for any other activities they deemed necessary to get the word out in their zone. Most committees across the country created their own posters, leaflets, and other materials, personalizing them to speak directly to the residents of those areas and connecting local issues to broader concerns. Thousands of posters and leaflets were printed and circulated in Vallekas alone. Every day, different collectives appeared at busy locations such as Metro exits and markets, handing out leaflets and asking if residents knew that a strike had been called and encouraging them to take part in it. Outside the Metro, in the early hours of the morning, some riders headed to work would ask activists if they could take leaflets with them to hand out at their workplaces. Special posters were created for businesses to hang in their windows declaring that they would be closed on the day of the strike. Signs promoting the strike hung across numerous Vallekas metro stops. On weekends, people set up information tables in public squares or parks; this proved especially effective for generating longer conversations with residents. As we donned our orange vests and approached people to strike up conversations, our objective wasn’t to talk at them about the strike. We simply aimed to ask them if they had heard about the strike and how they were impacted by the housing crisis. Often, residents would begin talking and find it difficult to stop, venting about the mounting housing issues that they and their loved ones have faced over the last few years. At the end of these conversations, we affirmed that these were problems that most of us were facing and explained what we were trying to do about them. This approach helped us to politicize these widely shared issues in conversations with the broader public while enabling those of us working in the local housing movement to learn about the specific issues our neighbors are facing. As the day of the strike approached, the number of actions scaled up, including hanging giant banners from highway bridges and actions at the buildings of major real estate companies. Most of the united strike committees organized marches through their neighborhoods to remind people that the day was approaching. In Madrid, public school teachers have been on strike since October 14; they both received support from those organizing the general strike and contributed to those efforts as well. People also organized anti-repression workshops to share what to do in case of police identification, detention, or brutality. A strike banner hangs over a highway near Vallekas. 11N The general strike was scheduled to last for 24 hours. In preparation, the united strike committees across Spain scheduled actions to begin from the moment the clock struck midnight. Both the committees and other collectives designated specific locations in their areas to serve as gathering and resting places. Volunteers signed up to prepare food and coffee throughout the day, since the strike also entailed a 24-hour pause on all consumer purchases. In Vallekas, things got off to an early start. What was meant to be a simple meet-up to visit businesses and remind them to shut down at midnight attracted such a large turnout that it became a march instead. Activists walked up and down the streets of the district, handing out flyers about the strike to passersby and speaking with employees at local businesses. Many other parts of Madrid held similar demonstrations to ring in the beginning of the strike. Marchers in the famous Lavapiés neighborhood in the center of Madrid managed to spontaneously close down the large Carrefour grocery store in the middle of the neighborhood. Real estate agencies, responsible for some of the worst ills of the housing crisis, shuttered their doors for the entire day in fear. A defensive poster on a real estate agency, reading, “We are not vulture funds / We are not speculators / We are people from the neighborhood!! / We are not here to make money off the neighborhood, we are here to grow alongside it.” Too little, too late. Throughout the day, informational pickets took place at strategic hubs of logistics, industry, transport, and commerce across the city. The decentralized nature of the united strike committees enabled local organizers to reach most of the most important locations in each district, attesting to the effectiveness of this decentralized organizing model. Valleka saw lively pickets at Mercamadrid, the largest wholesale distributor of fresh produce in Spain, one of the main city bus depots, and the logistics center of the postal service. Their objective was to inform employees as they entered their workplaces of their right to strike and convince them to walk out, while seeking to disrupt each site’s operations in the process. Highway roadblocks also took place throughout Madrid and across Spain. Strikers blocked nearly every major highway and motorway entrance to the city at some point throughout the day in Madrid, halting traffic and preventing strike-breakers from reaching their workplaces. Protesters joyfully hung banners from overpasses. Vallekas protesters block one of Madrid’s main highways. In response, mass police operations unfolded all over the city throughout the day, attempting to intimidate activists and brutalizing the public. Due to its historic association with anti-fascism, Vallekas was one of the major targets of these operations. Secret police and squad cars patrolled its streets from the very first hours of the strike, stopping, identifying, and searching anyone suspected of being an activist. Despite doing little more than exercising their legal right to conduct an informational picket, activists at Mercamadrid and the city bus yard faced attacks from police wielding pepper spray and batons, who arrested a small number of them. Officers used the rain as an excuse to conceal their badge numbers, refusing activists’ requests that they to identify themselves and threatening those who made such requests with detention or further violence. Yet police failed to repress the strike in Vallekas. Moving en masse to stay protected while organized into small groups for flexibility, activists often outmaneuvered the police to carry out their actions. At one point, a large group of protesters was able to close down one of the biggest grocery stores in Puente de Vallecas because the police were distracted by a different group of protesters that had closed down another grocery store a few blocks away. Store workers inside danced and celebrated with the protesters outside. One of the worst cases of brutality of the day took place at noon in Gran Vía, Madrid’s largest and most tourist-heavy commercial boulevard. Thousands of activists gathered there to peacefully shut down the global fashion stores that line the thoroughfare; they managed to block all traffic as well. This joyful moment was cut short when hundreds of riot police descended on the crowd, using pepper spray and beating any person within reach. One man was rushed to the hospital after an officer split his head open with a police baton. A picket at Gran Vía on the afternoon of November 11. News of these events inundated social media. Despite the police violence and the torrential rain, Madrid’s residents turned out in massive numbers for the day’s main demonstration, which shut down the center of the city. According to event organizers’ estimates, 600,000 people showed up, representing countless associations, groups, and collectives as well as all of the city’s united strike committees. The Protest Song Chorus, the Transfeminist Marching Band, and the Orchestra for the Revolution enlivened the soaked marchers with their music. As we marched through the soggy streets, the first figures of the day started coming in. According to the Confederación de Sindicatos de Inquilinas, 4.5 million workers—roughly 20% of the country’s workforce—were taking part in the strike. More than 40% of small businesses were closed for the day as the national economy saw a loss of over 2 billion euros in gross output. Turnout was particularly high in certain industries: 90% of automotive sector workers and dockworkers, 85% of meat industry workers, 82% of waste collection employees, and 75% of energy sector workers participated in the general strike of November 11. The demonstration in the city center celebrating the success of the strike remained peaceful. The crowds swelled with thousands of all ages and people from all walks of life, including many who had never joined a protest before. The march was scheduled to last until 8 pm, but because of the rain and the tremendous number of people who had joined, only part of the march had reached the end point at the Plaza de España by that time. This has never been an issue in any of the countless demonstrations that have taken place in the city center. Nonetheless, without any provocation, hundreds of riot police surrounding the march suddenly began charging at the demonstrators. The riot police attempted to kettle thousands of protesters while simultaneously assaulting them with tear gas, pepper spray, and rubber bullets. The marchers panicked, trying to escape through side streets; police followed them, shooting rubber bullets directly at them at point-blank range and meting out baton beatings to anyone within their reach. In one video taken by a marcher, a group of officers are seen approaching a homeless man who was simply standing up from his spot on the sidewalk and pepper-spraying him in the face. It was impossible to identify the officers, who continued to hide their badge numbers. Police become violent during the strike demonstration, Madrid, November 11. The Spanish public immediately expressed outrage as images of police brutality appeared on the news and circulated via social media. The question on everyone’s lips was—how could this have happened under a supposedly progressive socialist government? Activists, politicians, and others demanded the resignation of Fernando Grande-Marlaska, Spain’s Minister of the Interior, who directs the National Police that attacked the demonstrators. Prime Minister Sánchez has refused to fulfil this demand. In the words of Spanish journalist Alejandra Martínez Velasco, “Someone is going to have to explain to me very slowly what difference there is between the images we saw from Gran Vía last night and the fascist monster they say is approaching.” Sánchez’s government presents itself as the last bastion against fascism, given the strong possibility that the right-wing People’s Party (PP) and extreme right-wing VOX Party could win the general election on November 29. But the reigning politicians’ complicity with police repression on the day of the strike shows that we cannot count on them, just as they have not pursued any effective action to address the housing crisis during their eight years in power. What we can count on is the massive grassroots activism that made the strike an tremendous success. This is the most resounding achievement of November 11. Street by street, neighborhood by neighborhood, workplace by workplace, common people worked together to bring 20% of the country’s workforce to a halt with barely any help from the mainstream state-proxy unions. This organizing has created deep bonds among those who took part in the strike. The networks that we have built in resistance to the housing crisis will help us to continue fighting in the days ahead, no matter which party wins the election. The View from Barcelona As the clocks struck midnight, fireworks exploded above the rooftops, lighting up the night sky across Barcelona. Strike committees across many of the city’s neighborhoods had agreed to gather to hail the first moments of the November 11th general strike together. People across the city, across Catalonia, across all of Spain had spent weeks preparing for this day. The day turned out to be momentous, filled with inspiring actions and different kinds of protests, revealing the strength of the movement while also shining a light on some of its present limitations. Perhaps the underlying energy of the day was best captured by the slogan that appeared on a large banner at the front of the demonstration that evening: “Viure! No Sobreviure” (“Live! Don’t just survive!”). The general strike was nothing less than a conflict between two different visions of life: the life of autonomy, compassion, and dignity that everyone who gathered on the streets and across the territory was fighting for, and the life of degradation, immiseration, and submission that is all that the political parties and the capitalist economy writ large offer to us. The banner at the front of the evening march reads “Live! Don’t Just Survive.” The weeks leading up to the general strike were marked by immense activity and debate. In neighboring France, militant student protests had already been raging for several weeks, a spontaneous and explosive uprising that appeared to be spreading wildly across Europe. The question of whether we were in a new global cycle of mass revolt hung in the air everywhere as people joined local strike committees and began to make plans—both in the formal space of meetings and informally between old friends and comrades who had experienced previous eruptions of struggle together. The recent explosion of the housing movement has felt novel and distinct in many ways, as it poses questions about resisting outside the sphere of labor, where they had traditionally been posed; but it also draws upon the rich history of radical spaces, autonomous organizations, and anarchist cultures that have long had deep roots in Catalonia. In this regard, we should understand the force that came together for the general strike as a culmination of countless different minor practices that blur the line between everyday life and political activity. It was the steady and patient history of communal meals, movie screenings, public debates, autonomous gyms, squatted buildings, neighborhood festivals, social centers, and too many other autonomous activities and infrastructures to name that, over many years, formed the rich soil from which this movement has grown, so that the strike does not appear as an exception to the norm but rather as a crest of an already rolling wave of radical ways of life. Strikers gather in the early morning to block roads. Once the sun began to rise over Barcelona on the morning of November 11 and people went out onto the streets of their neighborhoods, it was clear that the strike had already begun to transform the city from a space of work and commerce to a space of gathering and protest. Word quickly spread that several dozen highway blockades had shut down traffic across much of Catalonia—strike committees had been organizing in many small towns and villages to ensure that it wasn’t only the capital that would be disrupted and shut down. People had gathered early in the morning and marched onto the highways carrying large banners to block traffic; in some places, they created flaming barricades out of tires and other materials. A flaming barricade near Mataró, 25 miles from Barcelona. Meanwhile, many local strike pickets had already begun roaming throughout Barcelona’s neighborhoods, spray-painting slogans and wheatpasting posters on walls, gathering and chanting in front of businesses to pressure them to close, occasionally setting a trash bin on fire here and there along the way to keep the police busy. At midday, people converged in Plaça Universitat to block Gran Via, the main thoroughfare of the city, and also to be nearby the Casa de la Vaga (“the house of the strike”) which had been established at the university as a support center with food and medical services. Only a few streets away from Plaça Catalunya, where the protest encampment was still going strong, Plaça Universitat had already been surrounded by makeshift barricades assembled from trash containers that the morning’s picketers had dragged onto the streets. All the morning’s activity was only a prelude to the large demonstration that had been called for the evening, which was set to proceed down Passeig de Gràcia—the main commercial area of the city, lined with many luxury shops and international clothing chains. Several different columnas (feeder marches) departed from different parts of the city, chanting and carrying banners, eventually meeting at the demonstration’s starting point. Altogether, more than 400,000 people gathered to participate in the march, which was divided between different blocks represented by the various tenants’ unions, labor unions, Palestine solidarity groups, feminist contingents, and other elements of the radical milieu. More than 400,000 joined the evening demonstration. Spirits were high as it began to grow dark, a feeling that can only be experienced when you are among so many others all coming together to struggle for one another, for a better city, for better lives. Several batucada drumming groups provided rhythm for the gathering. Children sat on the sidewalk and painted messages onto some of the storefronts that had been boarded up in anticipation of the strike. The march was only about halfway down Passeig de Gracia when a couple dozen people wearing all black tried to join the march but were stopped from doing so. It is not at all uncommon to see people use black bloc tactics in Spain; everyone from student activists to anarchists to socialist militants all regularly dress in all black in order to resist police surveillance and repression. But this group appeared out of place, perhaps most notably because they came alone in small numbers and had unusually heavy builds, whereas typically, black bloc protesters are well-integrated within the wider demonstration, have an array of different body types, and already have relationships with other groups. Soon after they had been refused entry into the march and confronted as police infiltrators, several of them pulled out retractable metal batons and swung them at people. Then riot police vans quickly advanced upon the demonstration to defend them from an increasingly angry crowd. This provocation sparked the first militant conflicts of the night, with members of the demonstration coming out to push the police away from the march, throwing stones and metal barricades at the police vans, and firing a rain of projectile fireworks in their direction, forcing them to retreat as the crowds cheered. Demonstrators use fireworks to force riot police to retreat. After the police were successfully pushed back, protesters began tearing away the boards that concealed the storefronts and breaking their windows, tossing bags and shoes from within the stores to the crowds behind them. Others set various kinds of fires. As the tone of the march shifted, some people, especially those with young children in tow, decided that these attacks on businesses marked the end of the gathering and began to make their way home, while others remained and prepared for a fight with the police. Eventually, the crowds moved to Plaça Catalunya. Some people attacked the iconic Apple store that is located there while others took cover behind large banners, using lasers and throwing objects to keep the police at a distance. People constructed flaming barricades at several of the main intersections of the plaça to create a space to hold and defend. A strange calm set in for more than half an hour as the police repositioned themselves to try to retake the square. The entrance to the Apple store is set on fire near Plaça Catalunya. Eventually, many vans full of riot police stormed in and police assaulted whoever remained on the streets with clubs. The undercover police also returned and made many arrests. While Plaça Catalunya is a place of great symbolic importance, having been the location of many key events of the civil war as well as the site of the 15M encampments, its open layout and many wide connecting avenues make it very difficult to defend against police incursions. That was how the day of the general strike came to an end. The movement showed its strength but also arrived at an impasse, with an unclear future awaiting it. Fireworks serve to obscure the vision of riot police. In the days that followed the general strike, many formal and informal meetings took place to discuss what lessons could be derived from the day’s events. People began to organize support for the nearly fifty people who had been arrested, three of whom are still being held in prison. A demonstration occurred in the Clot neighborhood to support the arrested strikers, but massive numbers of police occupied the neighborhood in advance, searching everyone who arrived by metro and demanding their ID cards. While the city council and the police made a point of denouncing those who had set fires and fought the police on the night of the general strike, the tenants’ unions rejected this attempt to divide the movement into “good” and “bad” protesters—a promising sign as the movement continues to develop. But many questions remain unanswered. The movement has reached a stage at which it can draw many thousands of people into the streets, and the tenants’ unions seem poised to continue to grow in membership and strength as the housing and rental situation continues to deteriorate. But as the national elections approach at the end of this month, with a right-wing victory appearing likely, it is unclear what path forward the movement could pursue except for more of what we’ve already seen. A movement that is disinterested in the game of electoral politics has little to gain from purely symbolic displays of force, such as large marches; yet so far, the more combative elements of the movement have been too small to hold their ground against the repressive forces of the state. Perhaps the way forward can be found where the movement originated, in the neighborhoods, activities, and spaces that have given people their sense of autonomy and commonality, their sense that they have the power to organize their own lives and, one day, to destroy the power of capitalism and the state. At the meetings of the tenants’ unions, there is a feeling of building upon what has already been built, adding a new edge to an already vibrant ecology of community and resistance. But it is necessary to push further, to create a situation unlike any we have seen before. No one of us alone can answer the question of how we might do so. The answers must emerge from the ways that we live with one another, tie ourselves to one another, and fight for one another against a political system and an economy that are intended to isolate us. One of several flaming barricades built near Plaça Catalunya. Further Reading Fire Extinguishers and Fire Starters—A Report from the 15M Movement of 2011 “The Rose of Fire Has Returned!“—A Report on the General Strike of April 2012 After the Crest: Barcelona Anarchists at Low Tide From 15M to Podemos: The Regeneration of Spanish Democracy Anarchists on the Catalan Referendum of 2017 The Fight in Catalunya: Independence or Self-Determination? The Encampment Movement against Evictions and Gentrification

48 minutes ago • 1 votes
The Dynamic World of Gold, Migrations, and Strife That Came Before the Vikings

In 793 AD, longships landed on the shores of Lindisfarne in the Kingdom of Northumbria (modern-day England). Vikings poured out and put the inhabitants to the sword and the axe in what is considered by many historians to be the beginning of the Viking Age.   While this age is prominent in popular culture, […]

5 hours ago • 1 votes
A weird medieval gift guide volume II

More gifts from the annals of history!

2 days ago • 1 votes
Google Chrome dev team declares bug report bankruptcy

[ I wrote this in August 2012 and then forgot about it. ] About 18 months ago I filed a report for a bug in Google Chrome. It wasn't a very important bug. I reported that when Chrome was asked to inline an image, and the image turned out to be in the obscure and seldom-used X-bitmap format, it came up as a "broken image" icon (which isn't a bug) and failed to display the alt text from the img tag (which is). a page that demonstrated the problem. To see if the problem is still present, all you have to do is click the link in the bug report. next 40,000 reports are even worse, this is the strategy to adopt. What should Chrome have done here? There is an easy thing and a hard thing. Addenda A Mastodon colleague was complaining today about a similar practice, and I wanted to refer him to this article, but couldn't because I had completely forgotten to publish it. JWZ complained about something similar in 2003.

2 days ago • 1 votes
Sun Yat-sen at 160: His Legacy in Today’s China

A full translation of Xi's speech and notes on Beijing’s reading of Sun’s legacy, national reunification and rejuvenation

a week ago • 1 votes
📚 BoredReading

You seem to be enjoying this.

Join free to unlock everything.

Create free account

Already have an account? Sign in