Transactions are not an intrinsic part of a storage system. Any storage system can be made transactional: Redis, S3, the filesystem, etc. Delta Lake and Orleans demonstrated techniques to make S3 (or cloud storage in general) transactional. Epoxy demonstrated techniques to make Redis (and any other system) transactional. And of course there's always good old Two-Phase Commit. If you don't want to read those papers, I wrote about a simplified implementation of Delta Lake and also wrote about a simplified MVCC implementation over a generic key-value storage layer. It is both the beauty and the burden of transactions that they are not intrinsic to a storage system. Postgres and MySQL and SQLite have transactions. But you don't need to use them. It isn't possible to require you to use transactions. Many developers, myself a few years ago included, do not know why you should use them. (Hint: read Designing Data Intensive Applications.) And you can take it even further by ignoring the transaction layer of an existing transactional database and implement your own transaction layer as Convex has done (the Epoxy paper above also does this). It isn't entirely clear that you have a lot to lose by implementing your own transaction layer since the indexes you'd want on the version field of a value would only be as expensive or slow as any other secondary index in a transactional database. Though why you'd do this isn't entirely clear (I will like to read about this from Convex some time). It's useful to see transaction protocols as another tool in your system design tool chest when you care about consistency, atomicity, and isolation. Especially as you build systems that span data systems. Maybe, as Ben Hindman hinted at the last NYC Systems, even proprietary APIs will eventually provide something like two-phase commit so physical systems outside our control can become transactional too. Transactions are a protocol short new post pic.twitter.com/nTj5LZUpUr — Phil Eaton (@eatonphil) April 20, 2025

This is an external post of mine. Click here if you are not redirected.

Last month I completed my first year at EnterpriseDB. I'm on the team that built and maintains pglogical and who, over the years, contributed a good chunk of the logical replication functionality that exists in community Postgres. Most of my work, our work, is in C and Rust with tests in Perl and Python. Our focus these days is a descendant of pglogical called Postgres Distributed which supports replicating DDL, tunable consistency across the cluster, etc. This post is about how I got here. Black boxes I was a web developer from 2014-2021†. I wrote JavaScript and HTML and CSS and whatever server-side language: Python or Go or PHP. I was a hands-on engineering manager from 2017-2021. I was pretty clueless about databases and indeed database knowledge was not a serious part of any interview I did. Throughout that time (2014-2021) I wanted to move my career forward as quickly as possible so I spent much of my free time doing educational projects and writing about them on this blog (or previous incarnations of it). I learned how to write primitive HTTP servers, how to write little parsers and interpreters and compilers. It was a virtuous cycle because the internet (Hacker News anyway) liked reading these posts and I wanted to learn how the black boxes worked. But I shied away from data structures and algorithms (DSA) because they seemed complicated and useless to the work that I did. That is, until 2020 when an inbox page I built started loading more and more slowly as the inbox grew. My coworker pointed me at Use The Index, Luke and the DSA scales fell from my eyes. I wanted to understand this new black box so I built a little in-memory SQL database with support for indexes. I'm a college dropout so even while I was interested in compilers and interpreters earlier in my career I never dreamed I could get a job working on them. Only geniuses and PhDs did that work and I was neither. The idea of working on a database felt the same. However, I could work on little database side projects like I had done before on other topics, so I did. Or a series of explorations of Raft implementations, others' and my own. Startups From 2021-2023 I tried to start a company and when that didn't pan out I joined TigerBeetle as a cofounder to work on marketing and community. It was during this time I started the Software Internals Discord and /r/databasedevelopment which have since kind of exploded in popularity among professionals and academics in database and distributed systems. TigerBeetle was my first job at a database company, and while I contributed bits of code I was not a developer there. It was a way into the space. And indeed it was an incredible learning experience both on the cofounder side and on the database side. I wrote articles with King and Joran that helped teach and affirm for myself the basics of databases and consensus-based distributed systems. Holding out When I left TigerBeetle in 2023 I was still not sure if I could get a job as an actual database developer. My network had exploded since 2021 (when I started my own company that didn't pan out) so I had no trouble getting referrals at database companies. But my background kept leading hiring managers to suggest putting me on cloud teams doing orchestration in Go around a database rather than working on the database itself. I was unhappy with this type-casting so I held out while unemployed and continued to write posts and host virtual hackweeks messing with Postgres and MySQL. I started the first incarnation of the Software Internals Book Club during this time, reading Designing Data Intensive Applications with 5-10 other developers in Bryant Park. During this time I also started the NYC Systems Coffee Club. Postgres After about four months of searching I ended up with three good offers, all to do C and Rust development on Postgres (extensions) as an individual contributor. Working on extensions might sound like the definition of not-sexy, but Postgres APIs are so loosely abstracted it's really as if you're working on Postgres itself. You can mess with almost anything in Postgres so you have to be very aware of what you're doing. And when you can't mess with something in Postgres because an API doesn't yet exist, companies have the tendency to just fork Postgres so they can. (This tendency isn't specific to Postgres, almost every open-source database company seems to have a long-running internal fork or two of the database.) EnterpriseDB Two of the three offers were from early-stage startups and after more than 3 years being part of the earliest stages of startups I was happy for a break. But the third offer was from one of the biggest contributors to Postgres, a 20-year old company called EnterpriseDB. (You can probably come up with different rankings of companies using different metrics so I'm only saying EnterpriseDB is one of the biggest contributors.) It seemed like the best place to be to learn a lot and contribute something meaningful. My coworkers are a mix of Postgres veterans (people who contributed the WAL to Postgres, who contributed MVCC to Postgres, who contributed logical decoding and logical replication, who contributed parallel queries; the list goes on and on) but also my developer-coworkers are people who started at EnterpriseDB on technical support, or who were previously Postgres administrators. It's quite a mix. Relatively few geniuses or PhDs, despite what I used to think, but they certainly work hard and have hard-earned experience. Anyway, I've now been working at EnterpriseDB for over a year so I wanted to share this retrospective. I also wanted to cover what it's like coming from engineering management and founding companies to going back to being an individual contributor. (Spoiler: incredibly enjoyable.) But it has been hard enough to make myself write this much so I'm calling it a day. :) I wrote a post about the winding path I took from web developer to database developer over 10 years. pic.twitter.com/tf8bUDRzjV — Phil Eaton (@eatonphil) February 15, 2025 † From 2011-2014 I also did contract web development but this was part-time while I was in school.

This is an external post of mine. Click here if you are not redirected.

I was so intimidated to go at first, but it is in fact easy and fun to start playing beginner volleyball in New York. The people are so friendly and welcoming that it has been easy to keep playing consistently every week since I started for the first time this August. It's been a great workout and a great way to make friends! The two platforms I've used to find volleyball games are Goodrec and New York Urban. While these platforms may also offer classes and leagues, I mostly use them to play "pickup" games. Pickup games are where you show up and join (or get assigned to) a team to play for an hour or two. Easy to go on your own or with friends. I'm not an expert! My only hope with this post is that maybe it makes trying out volleyball in New York feel a little less intimidating for you! Goodrec With Goodrec you have to use their mobile app. Beginner tier is called "social" on Goodrec. So browse available games until you find one at the level you want to play. You enroll in (buy a place in) sessions individually. Sessions are between 90-120 minutes long. They ask you not to arrive more than 10 minutes early at the gym. When you arrive you tell the gym managers (usually in a desk up front somewhere) you're there for Goodrec and the tier (in case the gym has multiple level games going on at the same time). Then you wait until the Goodrec "host" arrives and they will organize everyone into teams. Goodrec hosts are players who volunteer to organize the games. They'll explain the rules of the game (makes Goodrec very good for beginners) and otherwise help you out. Always say thank you to your host! New York Urban With New York Urban, pickup sessions are called "open play". There is no mobile app, you just use the website to purchase a spot in a session. The sessions are longer and cheaper than Goodrec. But there is no host; players self-organize. The options are more limited too. You play at one of four high schools on either a Friday night or on Sunday. And session slots tend to sell out much more quickly than with Goodrec. Big City Volleyball You can also check out Big City Volleyball but I haven't used it yet. Volo I haven't ever done Volo but I think I've heard it described as "beer league". That even some of the beginner tier sessions with Goodrec and New York Urban are more competitive. But also, Volo is built around leagues so you have to get the timing right. Goodrec's and New York Urban's pickup games make it easy to get started playing any time of year. Making friends It was super awkward to go at first! I went by myself. I didn't know what I was doing. I couldn't remember, and didn't know, many rules. I didn't have court shoes or knee pads. But the Goodrec host system is particularly great for bringing beginners in and making them feel welcome. You have a great time even if you're terrible. The first game I went to, I tried to hang out afterward to meet people. But people either came with their SO or with their friends or by themselves so they all just left immediately or hung out in their group. So you can't just go once and expect to make friends immediately. But if you keep going at the same place and time regularly week over week, you'll see familiar faces. Maybe half the people I play with each week are regulars. If you're friendly you'll start making friends with these people and eventually start going out to bars with them after the games. Improving Even if you find yourself embarrassingly bad at first, just keep going! I'm 29, 6'1, 190lbs and from observation the past 5 months, age, height, and weight have a very indirect relation to playing ability. Most of the people who play are self-taught, especially at the lower tiers I've played at. But some people played for the school team in high school or college. These people are fun to play with and you can learn a lot from them. Most people who are self-taught seem to watch YouTube videos like Coach Donny, helpful for learning how to serve, set, block, etc. Or they take "clinics" (classes) with Goodrec or other platforms. (I have no idea about these, I've never done them before.) At first I played 2 hours a week and I was completely exhausted after the session. Over time it got easier so I started playing 2-3 sessions a week (6-9-ish hours). With practice and consistency (after about 3-4 months), I started playing Intermediate tier with Goodrec and New York Urban. And I don't think I'll play Beginner/Social at all anymore. I still primarily play for fun and for the workout and to meet people. But it's also fun to get better! I played with one person much better than myself in an Intermediate session one time and he mentioned he will probably stop playing Intermediate and only play High Intermediate. He mentioned you get better when you keep pushing yourself to play with better and better players. Good advice!